User Reviews for Mary Elaine's

Research User Reviews for Mary Elaine's (1-2 of 2)

• Add Your Own Review »

Nov 9, 2007 by Michael Evans from new york
Overall Rating: 5
Food:[5] • Service:[6] • Atmosphere:[9]

• The view.
• Overcooked food, portions, and price.

“A joke! Six of us had dinner last week and none of us thought it anything close to the big city guys, Daniel, Keller, Trotter, Mina, etc. My halibut was over cooked and served cold. The filet wasn't anything that couldn't be found in any other estab. In town. The scallops were overcooked and the Caesar Salad served with one of the main courses was not more than two small green leaves dressed. No one ordered a dessert for not one sounded appealing. Very, very disappointed. We would have paid more than the overpriced menu if the food warranted it, for the view is that special. If you want the view go to Elements. If you want the food try Roaring Fork, Wild fish or Christopher.”

May 22, 2007 by steve from scottsdale
Overall Rating: 8
Food:[7] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[7]

“Feels like you are sitting in a hotel lobby, everyone asking how is everything while you are eating, had the Kobe steak tasted like a good London broil not bad, but at least put more than 3 tiny carrots and 2 half-dollar size fried potatoes on the plate. I was there in season and it looked like a ghost town. ”

1 of 1 people found this review helpful.