User Reviews for McMahon's Prime Steakhouse

Research User Reviews for McMahon's Prime Steakhouse (1-1 of 1)

• Add Your Own Review »

Feb 1, 2008 by Joe from Tucson
Overall Rating: 6
Food:[6] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[9]

• Decor, service, wine list.
• The food! Exorbitant price, low on quality steak. Blah.

“For the money, you can find better steak elsewhere (Sullivan's Steakhouse in Tucson tops this restaurant hands down - no contest at all). We ordered the rib eye and it was quite disappointing. The cut didn't seem as tender and flavor as other rib eyes I have tried. Believe me when I say I know my steak (Smith & Wollensky, NY, Union Sq Grill, Seattle, among others). I'm not sure why others have rated this restaurant so high. This restaurant seems to have built it's name from the owner who started other restaurants in Tucson. But it is totally out of character to charge $35 for steak and yet be so woefully lacking in quality piece of meat. Granted the decor, service, and the wine list is exceptional. But when you are charging $35 for steak, you better bring your A-game not some chuck wagon beef on a plate. In summary, try Sullivan's. It happens to have a sister restaurant named Del Frisco's in NY that I would also recommend.”