User Reviews for Hurleys Steak & Seafood House

Research User Reviews for Hurleys Steak & Seafood House (1-1 of 1)

• Add Your Own Review »

Nov 27, 2008 by Diana from Miami, FL
Overall Rating: 1
Food:[2] • Service:[1] • Atmosphere:[7]

• The butter was tasty, akin to hand-churned Danish butter.
• This is a glorified sports bar disguised as a restaurant with a menu to match. I am sure if we ordered wings & fries my review would have been a 10. The location and upstairs steakhouse furnishings lure you into believing a steak would be tasty.

“Basically, this is a sports bar with an upstairs restaurant set in 1800's steakhouse saloon decor. Very deceiving, as it is warm & rather clean for NYC. Breakdown on the meal: rolls were 2-day old & reheated; butter was the highlight of the meal; salad was below McDonald's quality; steak was large, but very tough; pasta was overcooked & sauce was bland; chicken was tough & rubbery; pork medallions were an absolute joke, 3 silver-dollar sized & 1/4" thin, and without taste to boot; chicken pot pie was white gravy poured over undercooked veggies, not even worthy of feeding to dog! Service was even worse, if you can imagine that! Never saw the wait staff after service, never had drinks refilled, had to share utensils because staff was nowhere to be found.”

1 of 1 people found this review helpful.