User Reviews for Sammys Cider Mill

Research User Reviews for Sammys Cider Mill (1-2 of 2)

• Add Your Own Review »

Feb 26, 2007 by Melissa from Peapack, NJ
Overall Rating: 2
Food:[2] • Service:[1] • Atmosphere:[1]

• Easy parking.
• Everything else.

“Food was awful, steak was full of grizzle, desserts were nothing to speak about service was non-existent. Not a comfortable experience at all. Waiting in the basement seemed silly since the place was almost empty. I have no problem paying for a good meal but $400.00 for four people was very extreme at this place. I would not suggest you waste your time or money.”

Aug 12, 2006 by Madyson from Chester
Overall Rating: 8
Food:[10] • Service:[7] • Atmosphere:[5]

• Really good lobster, steaks and FABULOUS fries.
• Atmosphere is what I would call rustic umm, very rustic.

“Fantastic food, very expensive especially for it being located in an old house. Waiting in the basement for a table always feels interesting. It is like waiting in someone's finished basement game room only the games are a dollar or more a game.”