User Reviews for New York Restaurants

Research User Reviews for New York (1-20 of 2019)

• Add Your Own Review »

Mi Tierrita Restaurant
Oct 31, 2009 by Jennifer from Nieto

Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Very thing is wonderful.
• The waiting time.

“The best Colombian restaurant on Long Island, the service is great and the people are very friendly you feel like you are at home and you know this people for a long time. The food is wonderful. I would recommended too anyone. Mi Tierrita Restaurant is the Best!”

Tony Sparagna's Restaurant
Oct 30, 2009 by Michael from Melbourne FL

Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• I can't eat more.

“Go there. It is a glimpse of what the old Italian neighborhood of Utica used to be. It is a place for good Italian gravy red sauce, macaroni pasta, a Utica Club beer. If those things mean something to you, then go. If not, go and find out! If you are Italian, you owe it to your stomach. The patrons and the staffs are the nicest people you'll ever meet.”

Friendly's
Oct 27, 2009 by John from Amawalk

Overall Rating: 2
Food:[2] • Service:[2] • Atmosphere:[1]

• Convenient location, adequate parking.
• Dirty, tattooed, surly teenage servers, dirty floors and restrooms.

“Slow service, not clean, indifferent food. The floor was dirty, the menu was dirty. I worked at a Friendly's years ago when I was in college. This place is definitely not up to standards.”

Maple Haven Farms Restaurant
Oct 25, 2009 by Mary from Stafford

Overall Rating: 8
Food:[8] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[7]

• Fish Fry was great and they have awesome breakfast!
• Building could use some work.

“We loved Maple Haven. While the building may be old, the food was great and the service was excellent. The other customers were friendly and extremely helpful in helping us with local directions. I would definitely eat there again.”

Country House Restaurant At Stony Brook Ltd
Oct 24, 2009 by allan from danville,ky

Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Atmosphere is a 10 plus, clean like your home.
• We cant get there often enough.

“Every time we come in to town we eat there, incredible food,service,and atmosphere. The owner is without a doubt the best host and so helpful. Wish all the restaurants had what this young man has, a class operation with great food.”

Fortune Garden Restaurant
Oct 20, 2009 by George from Miami

Overall Rating: 9
Food:[9] • Service:[8] • Atmosphere:[8]

• Good food, plenty of parking.
• Should be relocated 1500 miles to Miami.

“Wish this establishment would relocate to Miami. All the food is fresh and the dishes were very spicy and tasty. The garlic chicken and hunan beef are my favorites.”

Laguna Restaurant
Oct 15, 2009 by Marie from NY

Overall Rating: 2
Food:[5] • Service:[1] • Atmosphere:[5]

• The bus boys.
• Staff, wait, food, and manager.

“We should have known when we walked in on a Friday night. With all of the open tables they sat us right next to the kitchen. The food was pricey but we didn't mind. When our food took over one hour, and the Eggplant was burnt then we were not pleased at all. The manager practically laughed it off and once we complained, the servers never came by again. What a disappointment. I have never been treated so rudely for mediocre at best food.”

2 of 2 people found this review helpful.

Quinta Steakhouse
Oct 13, 2009 by Roy from Montvale

Overall Rating: 1
Food:[2] • Service:[5] • Atmosphere:[3]

• Close to home, so I didn't have to wait to use my bathroom.
• Food.

“Just terrible food, enough salt in every item to raise your blood pressure 100 points. The food was fatty, undercooked, lacked any flavor, the fries, drenched in oil, with a bottle of salt. Stay away from this so called steak house and to add insult to injury, they rush to leave after you finish your meal. Wife's Stuffed Fish was right out of the freezer, and into the microwave!”

Wok And Roll Cafe
Oct 13, 2009 by Pamela from Southport CT

Overall Rating: 9
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[7]

• The food is excellent, a light touch with much subtle Asian flavors.
• The ambiance is not as lovely as the original location, but still is nice and cozy in a wonderful place in town.

“The head chef and owner of Wok and Roll had been with the original Little Bear in Bearsville, just on the other side of Woodstock years ago. He still has his magic touch and the dishes, particularly those with his special signature are truly excellent. He has a light touch and each plate is full of flavor, and so very nicely presented. Having not been back to Woodstock for years, it is wonderful that this lovely Chinese treasure is still in town! Looking forward to a repeat visit soon.”

Yianni's Steak & Seafood Inc
Oct 13, 2009 by john from rochester

Overall Rating: 4
Food:[5] • Service:[2] • Atmosphere:[5]

• Location.
• Service.

“We have eaten here three times and the third, unfortunately, was our last. The food is only average and the staff could use some training in friendliness. We eat out several times a week and there are many other places in this area to go where we feel welcome and appreciated for our business. Thank you.”

Quinta Steakhouse
Oct 12, 2009 by Roy from Montvale

Overall Rating: 4
Food:[3] • Service:[7] • Atmosphere:[5]

• Cleared the table in record time.
• Just about everything.

“The food was the worst I have ever had, fatty, undercooked, no flavor. The fries that came with, were so salt covered and oily that I had sickness for two days. They give you the buns rush on a Saturday night, couldn't have forced you out sooner. My wife's stuffed fish, came right out of the freezer into the microwave, definitely not made on premises. Then there's the noise factor, the acoustics are terrible, the sounds resound against the walls, totally unpleasant dining experience and not inexpensive.”

Glen Iris Inn
Oct 12, 2009 by Frank from Manlius, NY

Overall Rating: 6
Food:[5] • Service:[5] • Atmosphere:[9]

• Historic and beautiful restaurant by a magnificent waterfall.
• Ordinary food and service should be history.

“If the food was as good as the ambiance, the Glen Iris would be a hit. Ordinary food at extraordinary prices served by a waitress.”

Panza's Restaurant Inc
Oct 10, 2009 by Tom from Saratoga

Overall Rating: 7
Food:[8] • Service:[8] • Atmosphere:[8]

• Good food!
• Do not accept Entertainment Coupons after 6:00 p.m. on Saturdays.

“Decent atmosphere. Food is good but pricey for the value. If you are going to be using an Entertainment Coupon they are not accepted after 6:00 pm on Saturdays.”

Shaffer Cy Oyster Bar & Grill
Oct 10, 2009 by Lee from Phoenix

Overall Rating: 9
Food:[9] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[9]

• Great food, service, atmosphere.
• Loose toilet seat in the restroom showed poor concern for ladies.

“Shaffer City Oyster B&G is one of those perfect date or meeting restaurants. It's quiet, with excellent food and service. Most nights feature personalized attention from the owner himself. Nice private back room for special meetings or celebrations.”

Ripe Tomato An American Grill
Oct 9, 2009 by Rachel from Balltson Lake

Overall Rating: 9
Food:[10] • Service:[8] • Atmosphere:[8]

• Great atmosphere, amazing food, friendly folks.
• Can sometime be a wait to get seated on a busy Fri or Sat night. Reservations recommended.

“I've been to the Ripe Tomato many times over the years and have always had a pleasant and memorable experience. Whether I am looking for a romantic dinner for two or to take the family out for Sunday brunch or even for a corporate lunch on meeting which I have done there twice now, the atmosphere at this place just always seems to fit because if the way that the space is broken up. As for the food, the restaurant has some unique and inspired dishes and also some classic favorites and I always find myself impressed with the flavor combinations. Truly a great restaurant for those who enjoy delicious cuisine. I would highly recommend.”

The Nugget Bar
Oct 9, 2009 by TOM from MONGAGP VALLEY

Overall Rating: 8
Food:[10] • Service:[8] • Atmosphere:[9]

• Great food - very clean.
• Can be a little noisy in the front dinning room but they have a second rear room.

“I have visited numerous times and the food is fantastic and the prices are very reasonable. Everything is made to order so sometimes it requires a little extra time to be served but it is well worth the wait.”

Casa Rustica
Oct 8, 2009 by Nunzio from ny

Overall Rating: 9
Food:[9] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[9]

• This place is unbelievable.
• Nothing negative to say.

“The food is top notch. Atmosphere is very trendy and is done with taste. Service was excellent. Highly recommended.”

Lushane's
Oct 8, 2009 by Nathalie from Nyack

Overall Rating: 2
Food:[1] • Service:[3] • Atmosphere:[3]

• Appetizer fried calamari was good.
• Main courses, stale wine, dessert.

“I just recently moved to Nyack. One of the reasons for choosing this river town was the availability of good restaurants. Therefore, I was very excited to try Lushane's, especially having read such amazing reviews. Granted they were dated and I ate there on a Wednesday night. Yet, that it was a weekday is hardly an excuse for serving food that was mediocre at best. The butternut squash ravioli was a completely bland disappointment. The special pork tenderloin was overcooked and the sides were tasteless. The red snapper special was also overcooked and the presentation was ridiculous. And, as if it weren't bad enough, the Crianza I was served had surely been sitting around for a while. For the prices, one expects so much more. I won't be going back ever.”

11 Madison Park
Oct 7, 2009 by Ryan from Chatham nj

Overall Rating: 9
Food:[9] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[9]

• Great knowledgable staff, and bartendars. Top notch ingredients.
• Wish I could afford to stop in daily.

“First class all the way. It's the perfect sophisticated upscale place for a night out or a client.”

Johnnys Take-Out Svce
Oct 7, 2009 by Sarah from West Seneca

Overall Rating: 2
Food:[8] • Service:[1] • Atmosphere:[5]

• Food is always good.
• Rudest delivery people on the planet.

“I placed an order for delivery, and when my food was brought to my office the delivery person threw my change at me - this is after I paid extra for the delivery. Too bad, I used to love this place - but I will not be giving them any more of my money. Rudest delivery person I have ever encountered, and for absolutely no reason at all. You should be ashamed Johnny's!”

V & R Restaurant And Pizzeria
Oct 6, 2009 by Anne from Albany

Overall Rating: 4
Food:[4] • Service:[5] • Atmosphere:[9]

• The place is pleasant.
• Our wait person did not know the deserts. He told us one and we listened to another from another person.

“We used to eat at V&r quite often and I do not know why we changed. We had a so-so meal tonight. We wandered in having forgotten about restaurant week. The bread was warm and good. My salad was not very good: a small plate with the greens whole so you had to cut them on the small plate. I had one lettuce leaf with a large bad hole in it. The tomato had been refrigerated so forget that. My husband had the lasagna which was large and not very good. I had the shrimp scampi. The shrimp was overcooked as was the pasta. The sauce was too runny. Will we go back I doubt it.”

Riverview Restaurant
Oct 6, 2009 by Audrey from Massapequa Park NY

Overall Rating: 9
Food:[9] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[9]

• Everything.
• Nothing.

“One of the finest restaurants I have eaten in, in a long time. We on long Island are surrounded by water but there are very few really good seafood restaurants. This is one! On a recent visit. The cold seafood platter was excellent and plentiful the desserts were to die for especially the Bobbe. Coffee freshly brewed service concerned and friendly. My husband and I dine out often in and around the Island and some of the best restaurants in Manhattan River view can hold it's own with any restaurant in the Metro area.”

Cafe Dolce
Oct 5, 2009 by ANGELA from PATTERSON, NY

Overall Rating: 3
Food:[6] • Service:[1] • Atmosphere:[3]

• Appetizers.
• Service.

“The service here was the absolute worst. The place is small with maybe six tables so we took seats at the bar. Ten minutes after we sat another couple, obviously friendly with the staff and owner, sat at the bar next to us. Although they arrived after us and ordered after us, they received both their appetizers and entrees 10 minutes before us. While waiting for our entrees, we could here the kitchen ringing a bell to pick-up food, hoping it was ours. But the waitress/bartender continues to clean a table, take an order and serve drinks, while our food sat in the kitchen and then once we finally got it, arrived cold. The appetizers, carpaccio and beets with goat cheese were good, but the entrees skirt steak and chicken piccatta pasta, in addition to being cold were nothing above ordinary. I do not recommend a visit.”

Falls Diner Restaurant
Sep 29, 2009 by Bob from Connecticut

Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Amazing food, big portions, and good service.
• No negatives at all.

“The portions are huge and the food is amazing. And I was pleased with every single little detail of my experience. I only wish I could move next door and experience it every day.”

Magee Country Diner
Sep 27, 2009 by jeanne from rochester ny

Overall Rating: 7
Food:[7] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[7]

• The service was fairly fast although they were busy, friendly and efficient.
• Food was good but not great.

“September 2009. First of all, this restaurant is located at the corner of Routes 318 and 414. It is not on Pumphouse Road. That is the home of the owner! Three of us had lunch, one breakfast. The breakfast was very good. The Chicken Gary salad was good. The cheeseburger was good. The turkey sandwich while good was in little pieces. Side orders of fries are HUGE! The sweet potato fries are good. Nothing really spectacular. Nothing was bad. The fish sandwiches looked good. They were very busy but the service was pretty fast and friendly. It is near the throughway.”

Miyako Japanese Steak House
Sep 25, 2009 by Samantha from Altamont

Overall Rating: 9
Food:[10] • Service:[8] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Great food, atmosphere and staff.
• Some staff members need to work on their English.

“This is the best place I've eaten in. I have become a regular now, coming here at least once a week. It's beautiful and the staff is friendly. I highly recommend it.”

Ginos Tavern And Restaurant
Sep 25, 2009 by ziggy from wantage

Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[8]

• Friendly wait staff.
• Tough parking on busy nights.

“One of the best places I have ever been. Great food, service and prices.”

Four Brothers Pizza
Sep 25, 2009 by Melissa from Bronx, NY

Overall Rating: 1
Food:[2] • Service:[2] • Atmosphere:[3]

• The flowers outside.
• Everything else. Will never return!

“I am in the restaurant business. The restaurant I am in, is all fresh to order. I did not eat in Mahopac, I ate at the Four Brothers in Dover Plains. The service was horrific! A milkshake was ordered, a chocolate milk was brought. Asking for a burger, medium, with red onion and only Hellman's mayo. No red onion, lied about the mayo being Hellman's. The waitress wasn't sure at 1st, but then started reassuring me that they must have Hellman's. She never checked. Bread was brought, without plates. Garlic bread was ordered, it arrived burnt. My children wouldn't eat the French fries. They weren't cooked. However; my burger was a frozen, over cooked, hockey-puck, that I didn't eat either. The twister fries I ordered were ice cold, didn't eat that either. My son ordered a pizza. like rubber,again.”

Paradise Diner Restaurant
Sep 24, 2009 by mootsie from Ronkonkoma

Overall Rating: 5
Food:[3] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[5]

• The waitress.
• The atmosphere.

“The outside of the Diner is horrible, the grass is completely disastrous. When I went in the Diner there was blond haired lady at the register who seemed a bit annoyed that we were there. She brought us to a table and quickly walked away. The Waitress on the other hand was very vivacious and eager to take our order.”

Boss Crokers
Sep 22, 2009 by Jim from Wantagh

Overall Rating: 9
Food:[9] • Service:[7] • Atmosphere:[6]

• Hamburgers.
• Noise.

“Been a customer here for may years. Menu is limited but corkers makes a superb Hamburger. Order the Bacon Cheese Burger with Crisp Bacon (they actually know how to do that) with crunchy fries and you will be amazingly pleased. The ambiance is like a good old fashioned Bar & Grill. Thursday and Friday is very loud starting around 8:00 P.M. The food is great and service quick. Good for a casual meal. We don't order burgers from any place else.”

Dickies Donuts
Sep 22, 2009 by steve from fredericksburg, va

Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Very good donuts at very good prices, friendly staff.
• Nothing.

“In April 2009 I was on a road trip to Toronto and I stopped here for a pit stop. I've been driving 10 straight hours and needed something to tie me over. Well there it is, right off the NY expressway. Very cheap donuts, good quality, very tasteful, and friendly staff too! It took me 2 weeks to track down the name again so the next trip I take will be to dickies donuts.”

Sweethollow Diner
Sep 21, 2009 by Shannon from Mineola

Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[9]

• The food was delicious.
• I don't live nearby so I can go back all the time.

“We were in the area and stopped in for lunch. We were seated immediately. The place is clean and the management very friendly. I had the best Greek Salad with chicken ever. In fact, everyone's food was delicious.”

Charley Browns Restaurant
Sep 19, 2009 by Debbie from Fairport

Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[8]

• Love the food! Nice bar and warm atmosphere.
• In the winter not a lot of room for coats.

“Never had a bad meal and have taken lots of family and friends. There is something for everyone and always several specials of the day.”

City Line Deli Inc
Sep 19, 2009 by Jerry from White Plains NY

Overall Rating: 1
Food:[4] • Service:[2] • Atmosphere:[1]

• Coffee.
• Service, food, small cramped store, rundown.

“Very overpriced until a deli opened up across the street so they were forced to lower their prices. Place is dirty and small, employees are rude and food is below par. Coffee is pretty good though I will give them that. All and all I would not recommend going to this establishment.”

Cellar Restaurant
Sep 17, 2009 by Anne from Ithaca

Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Food, service, atmosphere, reasonably priced.
• None.

“Absolutely fabulous food with nice presentation, served by friendly staff. View of the river is beautiful, and the back room has a lovely setting for enjoying your meal. The Wed-music and special menu nights are a real treat, excellent music to accompany your excellent meal! The Cellar is my favorite place to dine in the area, rarely do you get such fabulous food in such a beautiful atmosphere for such a reasonable price! I give it top scores all around!”

Benny's Ristorante
Sep 14, 2009 by Trish from NYC

Overall Rating: 8
Food:[8] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[8]

• Food cooked as requested.
• Decor a bit staid.

“Wary of leaving Manhattan for a local Long Island Italian restaurant, we were pleasantly surprised. The service was attentive and the food cooked as ordered. While the decor may be a bit staid, it is an excellent place to meet friends for a dinner in a non-rushed atmosphere. They try to please and you will not leave hungry.”

La Manda Restaurant
Sep 14, 2009 by Andrea from Yorktown

Overall Rating: 8
Food:[9] • Service:[8] • Atmosphere:[5]

• Tilapia dish was excellent.
• Bar area a little too dark.

“Good food, good service, disappointed that they did not use fresh mushrooms on the veal Marsala. but it tasted delicious. If they have the Tilapia (st. Peters fish) get it, it was awesome.”

Applebee's
Sep 13, 2009 by Skitty from Ottawa

Overall Rating: 5
Food:[5] • Service:[3] • Atmosphere:[7]

• Price.
• Service, some food.

“My husband, two kids and mother recently took a trip to Watertown to do some back to school shopping. One of the main reasons we go to town is to have our meals at the local Applebee's which has always had the best steak and wonderful service. We were seated by a server who informed us that our server was on a dinner break and she would take our drink and meal order and would be with us shortly. We received our beverages and appies (from a runner) and waited about 25 minutes to receive our meal (also by a runner). Four of us had ordered steak and all of the plate bottoms were full of water, I assume from the vegetables. Not very appetizing. We were in need of drink refills, when the server finally stopped by the table. He didn't ask if we needed anything but raised his eyebrows as if to so Well? We ordered more drinks and he returned with a sour face an attitude that said he was doing us a favor. He didn't stop by again and we had to ask someone else for the last drink refill. We decided to give it a go the next night and the service was even worse. I asked the bartender if there was a comment card we could fill out and she said that we could speak to the manager. I didn't really want to do that, but he wandered over and asked if there was a problem and I explained the situation. He looked unconcerned and said that sometimes that happens. We have always enjoyed our visits to this Applebee's but think that it has gone downhill.”

2 of 2 people found this review helpful.

Meetinghouse Restaurant
Sep 10, 2009 by Evan from fairfield, CT

Overall Rating: 5
Food:[5] • Service:[4] • Atmosphere:[5]

• The new beer list caters to connoisseurs and regulars alike.
• The bar is a little small.

“The ownership has recently changed at this little local spot and all I can say is "Thank God." The food is ten times better as is the service and the prices are extremely reasonable. It seems as the new owners have dedicated themselves to revamping and drastically improving the menu. Also check out the interesting beers they have on tap.”

Sugar Loaf Cafe
Sep 8, 2009 by Patricia from NYC

Overall Rating: 8
Food:[8] • Service:[7] • Atmosphere:[7]

• Loved the dessert and coffee.
• Nothing.

“Being that I am from Brazil I understand the culture difference of Brasilia, North American. The way the waiters and owner talk, not accent, but use of words is sometimes a direct translation from Portuguese, which does not always work, and may be lost in translation and seem rude to an American. While the Brazilian person might think she is being courteous, she/he might be perceived as rude. My experience was fine, I really liked the coffee and desserts.”

Pleasantville Diner
Sep 7, 2009 by cookie from Pleasantville

Overall Rating: 1
Food:[2] • Service:[1] • Atmosphere:[1]

• Good and convenient locale.
• Food, staff, service, menu are all awful.

“This restaurant has the worst service, worst food but best location if you're using the train. Located directly across from the train station makes it a hot spot for coffee and breakfast early in the morning. The staff is rude and don't even try to stop in for snacks and coffee at dinnertime because they'll tell you that you're "taking a table" when no one is waiting at all. I stopped going there after getting a piece of pie with a huge hair baked into the center. Never will go there again.”

Cena 2000, Inc
Sep 7, 2009 by EJ from New York, NY

Overall Rating: 1
Food:[1] • Service:[1] • Atmosphere:[3]

• The ambiance
• Slow, rude service.

“I was lured into this restaurant by the warm, soft ambiance of the dining room. Little did I know this would turn out to be the worst dining experience that I've ever experienced in my life. We were seated far back in the outdoor seating, practically in the parking lot. With a party of 3, it took over an hour and a half from the time we were seated to the time that our entrees arrived. Meanwhile, several tables around us, including a table of seven who had arrived after us, and had a diabetic woman who threw a tantrum over the slow service, were served. The waiter was rude, unapologetic and shrugged off three requests for extra bread (we were given only 3 slices initially), as well as two inquiries about our appetizer by stating that he had 240 other customers to serve. The manager was reluctant to get involved and comped our original drinks and appetizer only after we pitched a fit. By that time I had a screaming headache and too angry to eat. What little I tasted of the Pasta was badly overcooked.”

Mariners Harbor On The Hudson
Sep 7, 2009 by phyllis from highland

Overall Rating: 2
Food:[2] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Location and feeding the ducks.
• Food and service.

“The only reason me & my husband went was because we had gift certificates to use. The first time we went, the service was as terrible as was the food. I don't know what kind of spices they use. Maybe they just make the recipe up as they go to cook which isn't bad if it tastes good at the end but it doesn't. The second time we went was just a few days ago the service was wonderful but the food was no better than the first time. My husband ordered mussels with fries thinking a side order of fries, but they put them on top of the mussels. Strange!”

Jerlando's Pizza Corp
Sep 3, 2009 by Siegfried from Ithaca NY

Overall Rating: 9
Food:[10] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[9]

• The food. if paradise has pizza catering, Jerlando's is certainly on their preferred suppliers list.
• Cannot think of anything.

“The pizzas of the place are in a class of their own. If you travel to Watkins Glen, visit Jerlando's Pizza. Either the one in Watkins Glen (you may encounter a long wait to be seated) or drive two miles and munch happily in Montour Falls at the Jerlando's there (which is said to have even better).”

Wall Warf Restuarant
Sep 2, 2009 by nina rochelle from melville new york

Overall Rating: 5
Food:[5] • Service:[7] • Atmosphere:[10]

• The view.
• Overpriced.

“Very small portions, overpriced. Potato chips out of a bag, they give some fancy name, and then they want to charge for a coffee refill!”

Spaghetti Kettle
Sep 1, 2009 by Brian from Clinton

Overall Rating: 1
Food:[1] • Service:[6] • Atmosphere:[6]

• None.
• Expensive, small portions, not tasty.

“Expensive and not good at all. Ordered spaghetti, was $10.00 for a plate without meat, $1.25 per meatball if you want them. Lasagna had an odd taste to it and was tiny, $12.00. Meals came with two small bowls of lettuce with one black olive in it. Also a small loaf of bread that was the only enjoyable item of this meal.”

Honeys Niagara Falls
Aug 31, 2009 by Larry from Gasport

Overall Rating: 2
Food:[1] • Service:[5] • Atmosphere:[1]

• Nothing.
• Food, filthy loud-mouth at outside bar.

“It was busy as it was Saturday evening (7 pm). We had to wait just inside the door and two other groups were ahead of us. About 15 minutes it was our turn. The lady skipped right over us and was going to seat what appeared to be some friends of her that were behind us and others. We spoke up as we had put our name in for seating. She apologized and sat us at an outside table which was fine. There were three of us (me, my wife, and our five year old grandson). The server was friendly and courteous (at first). When asked about a kids menu, he said they were out, but told us what was on it. We ordered the boy a hamburger meal but everything at the end was charged separately for a total of about $8. Way too much. After finding out it would be over an hour's wait for a pizza, we ordered something else. My wife got a chicken finger sub that was way overcooked. I ordered a Clam Strip dinner which came with French fries and Cole Slaw. The fries (which are supposed to be home made) were soggy with oil and limp. The Clam Strips were so undercooked that the batter was soaked with oil and falling off. There was so much oil saturated into the batter that I could ball up the batter on my plate. The Cole Slaw was tasteless. The grandson's hamburger was undercooked and still had almost raw meat in it, and the meal was cold. It must have sat around for a while. We decided not to complain to the server and ate what we could of the meal. While waiting for the check (almost 20 minutes) after we finished, the server came walking by and I had to ask for the check. While waiting for the check, a lady sitting at the outside bar was using language fitting for a steel mill. Her mouth should have been parked at a toilet instead of at the bar. Slinging out abusive words bombed like the fine trooper she was. Could hear her clearly and we were sitting at good 40 feet away. If you go there, don't sit outside near the bar, because I think she is a regular. We overheard our server and another worker verbally fighting each other.”

0 of 1 people found this review helpful.

Docksider Restaurant
Aug 30, 2009 by Sheila from Mystic, CT

Overall Rating: 4
Food:[2] • Service:[1] • Atmosphere:[9]

• Views of the lake.
• Food and service.

“What a disappointment! Although the view is spectacular, the service and food were horrible! Do not waste your time or $. We waited at the bar for our table which was fine, but we also got a view of the goings on in the kitchen. We watched as someone who might have worked there or maybe was just the local drunk, would visit the kitchen to pick food off customers plates and eat it! The staff was so overworked and stressed. We finally got a table and waited an hour just for our appetizers. Steamers, which were so dried out they were cracked! but, being diligent and hoping for the best we proceeded to wait another 45 minutes for our entrees! We finally had enough, and paid for our appetizers and got out of there! Tables all around us were complaining as well. And, the local drunk/employee was meandering thru and making a nuisance of himself. Too bad, this was the perfect setting for a great restaurant with much better management.”

The New Robin Hood Diner
Aug 29, 2009 by Mike from Manhattan

Overall Rating: 1
Food:[1] • Service:[1] • Atmosphere:[1]

• Not the only place to eat.
• Same old, same old.

“Ate there once, boring. Ate there last month, boring, ate there last year, boring. The place is a boring diner, that is in the beginning of town. Luckily, other eateries are in the town so you don't need to eat here. best of all, Liberty is a short drive and the food selection and amount of places to eat are plentiful. Don't waste your time here. The bar drinks are watered down and taste funny.”

Center Street Smoke House, Inc.
Aug 29, 2009 by Gena from Le Roy, NY

Overall Rating: 9
Food:[9] • Service:[8] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Excellent food. Excellent atmosphere. Spotless bathrooms. Awesome decor.
• Pricey.

“Delicious food. My mom found the chicken wings completely addicting! The building is much bigger inside than it looked from the outside! The booths are very big, the food is delicious, the decorations are VERY cool such as working phone booths, old punch-clocks and a turn-of-the-century phone. You can eat on the roof, on the second floor overlooking the first floor (if you can take the stairs), or sit on the ground floor where we did. I would have expected the bathrooms to keep the feel of your typical bar and grill but stepping into the women's bathroom, there was a classic feel and high level of elegance that Id compare to the powder rooms in the theaters where you might see Rent or something. Beautiful and spotless. The staff was friendly. My only complaint is the food is pricey (but their food holds up to such prices) and they ran out of the drink, my mother had wanted to order. But besides that, a terrific place and a surprising little gem well hidden in the tiny city of Batavia.”