User Reviews for Idaho Restaurants

Research User Reviews for Idaho (1-20 of 155)

• Add Your Own Review »

Shilo Conference Hotel - Idaho Falls
Oct 2, 2009 by Joyce from Portland,OR

Overall Rating: 9

• Helpful, friendly, and courteous staff were delightful.

“Good value for my money with this hotel made my trip enjoyable and comfortable.”

Second Avenue Pizza
Sep 15, 2009 by John from Tacoma, WA

Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[8] • Atmosphere:[9]

• Lots of cheese and toppings.
• Refills of pop not free.

“Great pizza. Service was mostly good, although it did take a little long to get a salad. Must pay for refills which is a minus. Went twice in three days because the pizza was so good.”

Shilo Conference Hotel - Idaho Falls
Sep 1, 2009 by Grace from Eden Prairie,MN

Overall Rating: 9

• Breakfast was great.
• None

“Excellent value for the money we paid.”

Shilo Conference Hotel - Idaho Falls
Aug 29, 2009 by Thomas from Idaho Falls,ID

Overall Rating: 8

• Big rooms.
• Could have been more modern.

“The facilities were great and the people were nice.”

Deer Cliff Inn
Aug 27, 2009 by Tarah from Orlando

Overall Rating: 9
Food:[10] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[10]

• The atmosphere and service were outstanding as well as the food was great.
• Too bad, it is not located on a highway.

“This is not your run-of-the-mill place. They offer many items on their menu that can only be found there. Such as: their own unique salad dressing, scones, desserts, etc. It is a wonderful place to relax by the cool river and get out of the noise and heat of the city or town. We went on a Friday evening and dined on their outdoor patio area. There was live entertainment that evening also. I noticed that they had some cute little cabins that could be rented for a very reasonable cost.”

Shilo Conference Hotel - Idaho Falls
Aug 23, 2009 by Stacey from Rupert,ID

Overall Rating: 10

“Guy
at the front desk was very friendly, upgraded our room from a king and sofa sleeper to two queen beds. Rooms were very big, clean, and comfortable.”

Carmella Vineyards
Aug 22, 2009 by Susan from Pocatello

Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• I said it all in my review.
• I wish that there could be more wine related items in the gift shop.

“My husband and I are regular attendee's of the Wine Maker's Dinner held four times per year. Each event is a themed evening, the last was Far East cuisine each course perfectly paired with wine. The chef is extremely talented. The owner is a most gracious host. We always have a wonderful time with friends eating and sampling wines in the wine cellar. Upstairs is a cozy bar with snacks and always someone fun to talk with. Carmella also has a comfortable dinning room that overlooks the beautiful Snake River. Across the street is the Carmella RV Resort. Stan is the man to see. Located next to the Carmella Golf Course, the accommodations are very nice, full service. This is one of our favorite places to take our RV.”

Mill Steaks & Spirits
Aug 21, 2009 by Stephen from Boise

Overall Rating: 4
Food:[3] • Service:[5] • Atmosphere:[6]

• Quaint decor.
• Food.

“I can cook better steaks at home after buying them at Costco. The meat was flavorless and overdone, the char marks are cute, but the steak literally tasted burnt. The vegetables were the consistency of baby food, perhaps a rubber-coated spoon should be supplied. Note: for my $35.00, I got bread, meat, pureed veggies and?”

0 of 1 people found this review helpful.

Shilo Conference Hotel - Idaho Falls
Aug 14, 2009 by Buddy from Evanston,WY

Overall Rating: 8

• Size of the room and view were well above average.
• Public areas are very rundown for a 3 star hotel.

“The rooms are very nice and very large. The view of the Snake river from the Balcony rooms is Fantastic. Great place for romantic getaway.”

Shilo Conference Hotel - Idaho Falls
Aug 4, 2009 by Bob from Nampa,ID

Overall Rating: 8

• great location and large rooms
• the beds were hard and the pillows too flat

“It was nice. I'd like to stay again (but bring my own pillow next time) and have more time to use the poolk and walk around the river-it was very nice.”

Shilo Conference Hotel - Idaho Falls
Jul 19, 2009 by Zoe from Abbotsford,Canada

Overall Rating: 7

• It was not renovated recently and the rooms reflected that.

“So far, my two stays with Shilo Inns have been less than what I expected. I can say from those experiences that they are not up to the standard where they should be.”

Gold Mine Eatery & Spirits
Jul 16, 2009 by Mary from San Diego

Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Service was great & friendly.
• No negatives at all here!

“Food was great, nice staff and bar. Dollar bills hanging all over the bar and dining area. Nice people, great food and even better prices.”

Shilo Conference Hotel - Idaho Falls
Jul 14, 2009 by Cheri from Providence,UT

Overall Rating: 10

• Price and cleanliness.

“Our stay was perfect.”

Shilo Conference Hotel - Idaho Falls
Jul 6, 2009 by Charles from Mountain Home,AR

Overall Rating: 10

• Free breakfast.
• Quality of free breakfast.

“Great place, at the price. Good for visitors to downtown. Easy access to highways.”

Shilo Conference Hotel - Idaho Falls
Jun 26, 2009 by Dan from Eden,NY

Overall Rating: 8

• Good location, good eateries in the area.
• In the process of needed upgrades remodeling.

“Good hotel in the process of upgrading room decor and carpeting.”

Shilo Conference Hotel - Idaho Falls
Jun 20, 2009 by Daniel from Vernal,UT

Overall Rating: 9

• I
  thought the room was very nice and the bed was extremely comfortable.
• The GFI plug for the bath room kept flipping off.

“It was a very pleasant stay at a beautiful setting on the river.”

Paupau's Kitchen, Inc.
Jun 18, 2009 by anonymous

Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Delicious foods and good service.
• Nothing.

“This is a very friendly take out or dine restaurant. This can be the best Chinese restaurant that I have been to.”

Paupau's Kitchen, Inc.
Jun 18, 2009 by anonymous

Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• They have the best food and service.
• Nothing.

“This is a really family/friendly restaurant. I just love their food. You can't compare their restaurant with other Chinese restaurants because their restaurant is like the best. I just love PauPau's.”

Shilo Conference Hotel - Idaho Falls
Jun 15, 2009 by Larissa from Boise,ID

Overall Rating: 10

• Very clean, friendly hotel.

“We really enjoyed this hotel and felt it was great value for the money. Everything was very clean and modern looking, the pool and hot tub were both good sized. The gym was nice with newer equipment. Would definitely stay here again!”

Shilo Conference Hotel - Idaho Falls
Jun 6, 2009 by Bill from Saint Paul,MN

Overall Rating: 5

• Free parking in downtown area.
• Smoking allowed inside hotel.

“Would not recommend to leisure or non-smoking travelers. Hard to get to from the interstate. Smoking allowed in hotel and lobby reeked of smoke. Downtown hotel with limited street parking but at least parking is free with stay. Room was small, couldn't get luggage dolly in the door without hitting desk and bed.”

Shilo Conference Hotel - Idaho Falls
May 13, 2009 by Collette from Springville,UT

Overall Rating: 7

• It seemed out dated and the out side was falling apart.

“I didn't stay long, just over night. The bed was nice and comfortable. It is close to the falls, the path is just out side. It's not the nicest/newest place to stay but it was worth the money.”

Shilo Conference Hotel - Idaho Falls
May 8, 2009 by Rebecca from Knoxville,TN

Overall Rating: 6

• Restaurant and bar in hotel, gym open 24 hours, front desk was
  friendly.
• Some
  very unprofessional staff, hotel in shabby and in need of remodeling.

“Fit the purpose of just passing through for travel. Pretty poor in appearance and decor, but mostly friendly staff. It was barely worth the money.”

Shilo Conference Hotel - Idaho Falls
Apr 19, 2009 by Robb from South Pasadena,FL

Overall Rating: 5

• The hotel has been almost completely renovated almost everything was redone and nice.
• The front desk didn't have it together, check in took over 20 minutes and there was only one other person and two desk clerks.

“The hotel property was great. Staff friendly and efficient, except for the front desk, which didn't have a clue what their job was. Beautiful view in a river front room. Nice balcony in each river front room. Breakfast (free) was above average.”

Remos Steak Sea Food & Pasta
Apr 3, 2009 by Helen Avila from Pocatello

Overall Rating: 1
Food:[1] • Service:[1] • Atmosphere:[2]

• When we left.
• Poor service, poor quality food, pricey.

“The food is expensive for small portions, soup is lukewarm. I ordered lettuce cups to be served with butter lettuce, got a tiny bowl of chicken from a package, 2 inch pieces of romaine, could not call it a lettuce cup (all for $9). Waited 1/2 hour to get a glass of water and menu and we were the only people in the restaurant I see why people don't eat there any more and I will never go again. I have tried over 2 years to eat there and each time the food and service get worse.”

Applebee's
Mar 21, 2009 by Russ

Overall Rating: 2
Food:[1] • Service:[1] • Atmosphere:[2]

• No wait.
• Over all not a good place to go, poor service and food.

“Food was obviously straight out of the microwave, different server brought my food, than the one that took my order I hate that. The tip goes down hill when that happens. Typical chain type place, expensive for the quality that you get. Weak drinks and very noisy place. Will not go there again.”

Shilo Conference Hotel - Idaho Falls
Mar 11, 2009 by Lisa from Billings,MT

Overall Rating: 10

• I liked the fact that this motel was not next to a highway, and located next to the river. The reception staff was friendly.
• The waitress for the buffet breakfast didn't seem to want to be there.

“I was pleasantly surprised in our room. It was spacious and the beds were actually comfortable! I always look for a hotel that offers breakfast when we travel, so this was perfect.”

Montana Steak House
Feb 18, 2009 by Sandra from Boise

Overall Rating: 9
Food:[10] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[8]

• Everything.
• Nothing.

“I don't live in Twin Falls but I make it a point to dine there whenever I am in town. The people are friendly and the food is fabulous!”

Hamburger Connection
Jan 29, 2009 by Russ from Middleton

Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Best fast food in Caldwell.
• Not enough indoor seating, so be ready to eat in your car during the winter.

“Great service, milkshakes, burgers and great owners!”

Garbonzo's Pizza
Jan 22, 2009 by Preston from Eagle Idaho

Overall Rating: 9
Food:[9] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Great pizza!
• Small and out of the way.

“This is a great restaurant The staff is friendly and the difference between them and your regular Dominoes is like night and day. The dough is freshly made and allowed to rise overnight.”

Vigilantes Restaurant & Lounge
Jan 16, 2009 by Cindy from Boise

Overall Rating: 6
Food:[6] • Service:[7] • Atmosphere:[2]

• The ribs are still good and burgers too.
• Prices are to high and the burgers smaller.

“Prices have raised why over what they use to be. To cold, and is just not what it use to be.”

Addies
Jan 13, 2009 by Bob from Boise

Overall Rating: 5
Food:[10] • Service:[1] • Atmosphere:[7]

• Consistently good food.
• Rude waitresses.

“The food is spectacular, but the servers seem to really hate their jobs. Addie's is great for take-out. The cooks make your food quickly, you can be on your way, and you don't have to deal with the waitresses.”

Snake River Grill Inc
Jan 10, 2009 by Walley from Boise,ID

Overall Rating: 4
Food:[7] • Service:[1] • Atmosphere:[2]

• My steak was cooked perfectly just looked a little smaller than six ounces.
• They were selling used light bulbs very tacky in my opinion. The light bulbs they were using were so bright and contain mercury which isn't exactly a vitamin for the environment.

“The entire visit to the grill was disappointing to all of us. Our waitress was to busy on the phone to refill our wine then we were very offended to see they had to sell their used light bulbs that I wasn't surprised when they tried to charge my credit card. We will not be recommending it my friends. Its to bad the food was wonderful.”

Stagecoach Inn Restaurant & Lounge
Dec 28, 2008 by Rick from White

Overall Rating: 6
Food:[5] • Service:[8] • Atmosphere:[7]

• Comfort food.
• The steak was not worth the price, tasted like it was from a cheaper franchise, greasy,oil taste to to prawns.

“I have been a patron of the Stagecoach for a long time due to my frequent travels to Boise. I always looked forward eating there especially - the fried prawns. I have to admit that the last few times though, I have been disappointed, it just hasn't been the same quality as before. Has anybody else noticed this?”

Canton Restaurant
Dec 23, 2008 by Mari from Nampa

Overall Rating: 8
Food:[10] • Service:[8] • Atmosphere:[5]

• Food - value - portion size.
• Decor.

“This is a wonderful restaurant in a small, dark (but clean) building. You go for the food - not the decor. Order a "Q" with all white meat - which is their mandarin chicken with pork fried rice. It's DELICIOUS! It's easy to find on the main drag one way street out of town - by the Wells Fargo bank.”

Melina's Restaurant
Dec 14, 2008 by Don from Blackfoot

Overall Rating: 8
Food:[9] • Service:[8] • Atmosphere:[8]

• Very friendly people, the food is great.
• It's so good that you may need to wait sometimes.

“First of all the red salsa is the bomb, I hope they never change it. The food is great, I've taken my family there a lot, because I used to live in Blackfoot, but now in Arizona, where you would think you could find a great Mexican restaurant. But to no avail. Melina's is the best yet.”

Berryhill & Company
Dec 9, 2008 by Laura from Boise

Overall Rating: 8
Food:[9] • Service:[6] • Atmosphere:[9]

• Good atmosphere and good food.
• Service was a little slow.

“I took my boyfriend here for his birthday. The atmosphere was very nice with a live piano player and modern, yet comfortable decor. The prices are at the high end, but you do get large portions. We did have to wait for 15 minutes, but the staff did a good job at making sure we had a drink and were comfortable. The service was average, but the overall experience was excellent!”

Craigo's Sourdough Pizza
Oct 18, 2008 by Cindy from Rexburg

Overall Rating: 7
Food:[9] • Service:[5] • Atmosphere:[7]

• The pizza bar!
• They took away there best products; the breadsticks and sour dough crust!

“I love the food. The lunch and dinner buffets are fantastic!”

Pancake House
Sep 28, 2008 by Julie from Moapa, NV

Overall Rating: 3
Food:[8] • Service:[1] • Atmosphere:[7]

• Food was good.
• Very unprofessional behavior.

“I came for the first time with my sisters (one of whom recommended it as she has been there before). Food was good, but we did not get served until l hour and ten minutes after we ordered. People came, were served, ate, and left all around us. Our waitress kept apologizing. We asked to see the manager. She refused to come and speak to us; simply told the waitress they were training new cooks. Never apologized. The waitress didn't charge my sisters-in-law for the 2 cinnamon rolls, but the rest of us felt a little stiffed. I will never go back, even though we will be spending a lot of time there, only because the management couldn't care less.”

0 of 1 people found this review helpful.

Perkins Family Restaurant
Sep 28, 2008 by Judith from Kearney, MO

Overall Rating: 5
Food:[1] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Everything except the food.
• The food was terrible.

“On September 9, 2008 my husband and I ate at the Perkins restaurant in Caldwell, Idaho. The restaurant was clean, inviting and warm feeling. The service was great. We both ordered the senior turkey dinner. We had eaten at the Perkins restaurant in Boise, Idaho about 10 days prior to the Caldwell Perkins visit. In Boise, Idaho we both ordered the senior turkey dinner. In Boise, the food was great, the service was great and the restaurant was warm and inviting. However, in Caldwell, the food was terrible. The mashed potatoes were instant potatoes made with water - in fact; they were actually runny from adding too much water. The turkey was dry - hard to tell about the dressing because there was so little of it. The salad was just big hunks from the center of the lettuce. On top of everything, I requested that they put plenty of gravy on the potatoes. I was informed that would be an additional 65 cents. In all fairness, I must say that the gravy was good. Neither my husband nor I are selective eaters - but I cannot overstate how terrible the food was at the Caldwell Perkins.”

China Inn
Aug 17, 2008 by Brandy from Clarkston, WA

Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[8]

• The food is served hot.
• The portions are larger than I can eat.

“This is my favorite restaurant in the area. The food is always fresh, hot, and delicious, with generous portions for the price. The atmosphere is pleasant and the service friendly.”

1 of 1 people found this review helpful.

China First
Aug 5, 2008 by tonya from boise

Overall Rating: 9

• The food is hot & fresh.
• If you are in a hurry, not a place you should go.

“The food here is always hot & fresh, but if you are from a big city please remember that their food is Americanized Chinese food, not authentic. I am a huge fan of the Cantonese stir-fried noodles. the service is slow, but it's worth the wait. If you aren't sure what you're ordering, ask the waitress, she is so friendly and will be happy to describe the dish in detail!”

Mill Steaks & Spirits
Aug 4, 2008 by Judy Carlisle from Tacoma Washington

Overall Rating: 5
Food:[1] • Service:[5] • Atmosphere:[8]

• Decor.
• Tasteless overpriced food.

“Will never recommend or go back. Prime rib was $22 and the 10 oz filet was 32$. They couldn't provide any tomatoes because they said the rate was up and down. Surprise all the other restaurants had them. It was a good thing my prime rib had au jus and horseradish because, except for the skin it was below Denny's standard. Margaritas were served in a tumblers. I would not recommend this restaurant to go - maybe you could get permission to walk around and look at the decor. After looking around, go down the street and around the corner to Steamers. Very professional staff, food is presented very artistically, delicious meals, they even have tomatoes.”

2 of 3 people found this review helpful.

Mandarin House Inc
Jul 25, 2008 by Nate from Filer

Overall Rating: 1

• They do have good food.
• They need to work on there people skills.

“It was the worst place I have ever eaten at. The people there messed up my order. Then when I tried to correct them, the manager was very rude. The manager then accused me of trying to get a free meal. In all actually I was trying to get what I ordered. I think they should be run out of business. Even the owner was rude, So if u asks me I think everybody should just join together and run these tyrants out of town. And get a new owner.”

0 of 3 people found this review helpful.

El Mirador
Jul 22, 2008 by Jan from Memphis,Tntn

Overall Rating: 9
Food:[9] • Service:[7] • Atmosphere:[9]

• Fast service, good atmosphere.
• Parking isn't very good when busy.

“The food is very good, margaritas are great. Usually good service.”

9 Beans & A Burrito
Jul 9, 2008 by Kent from Twin Falls

Overall Rating: 3

• Nice clean store.

“Small Portions.”

Shilo Conference Hotel - Idaho Falls
Jul 9, 2008 by Bart from Pittsburgh, PA

Overall Rating: 7
Food:[7] • Service:[7] • Atmosphere:[7]

• Good location on the Snake River. Nice and clean room.
• I was not initially given the room for which I asked and was not satisfied with the front desk's response to the problem.

“Nice hotel located on the Snake River. Great buffet-style breakfast and clean rooms. My only complaint is I requested a room with 2 queens and was given one with 1 king. When I inquired at the front desk the girl originally suggested my guest sleep on the pull-out couch. When I pointed out this was not satisfactory, I was given the room for which I originally booked. Definitely call this hotel immediately prior to your stay to confirm room choice. Get names from guest services.”

1 of 1 people found this review helpful.

Shilo Conference Hotel - Idaho Falls
Jul 1, 2008 by Julie from Henderson, NV

Overall Rating: 8
Food:[8] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[9]

• All rooms were suites, location, free buffet breakfast.
• Towels & sheets smelled of bleach, does not measure up to other 3 stars we've stayed in.

“The location was great - right next to the Snake River. A free buffet breakfast was included for my whole family. The rooms are being redecorated and it's nice to that all the rooms are suites. The bleach smell was a little overwhelming right outside the guest entrance and the towels and sheets also smelled heavily of bleach. I would recommend this hotel.”

A&W Restaurant
Jun 16, 2008 by D from Kuna

Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[8]

• Great smiley service.

“Skip the line at the overpriced and pretentious Goldy's and go a block down Main to Addies. Better value, better food. OK, the atmosphere is so old school it is almost cool again, but your tummy will be happier.”

Cabin Restaurant
May 11, 2008 by Peggy from Ellensburg, WA

Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Excellent home cooked food.
• Too bad the factory mall stores are empty.

“Home cooked food! Not only good food, but portions are not stingy, a lot of food for the money. We stumbled on the restaurant, sits back in part of Factory Outlet Mall that is mostly shut down.”

Dutch Goose The
Apr 1, 2008 by jim from boise id

Overall Rating: 2
Food:[1] • Service:[2] • Atmosphere:[2]

• Nice location out of Downtown on the way home.
• Poor nearly criminal service.

“We recently tried this place out on a recommendation of good clams which we found to be improperly cooked still holding quite a volume of sand I am a clam lover and could only palate 3 clams out of their $15.75 bucket which I could have chalked up to don't try the clams but in attempt to wash the sand down with a fresh pitcher of soapy sierra Nevada, I was disgusted and decided to complain, to which the bartender had no solution and gave me a look of so what! Then to add insult to injury while I was complaining a mentally challenged employee groped my wife much to the approval of the bartender who laughed! The bottom line is this place is bottom of the barrel I have had much more enjoyed meals from the dollar menu at McDonalds where the mentally challenged employees keep their hands to themselves.”