The New Robin Hood Diner

Photos of The New Robin Hood Diner, Livingston Manor

• Add your own photo of The New Robin Hood Diner

User Reviews for The New Robin Hood Diner

• Add Your Own Review »

Aug 29, 2009 by Mike from Manhattan
Overall Rating: 1
Food:[1] • Service:[1] • Atmosphere:[1]

• Not the only place to eat.
• Same old, same old.

“Ate there once, boring. Ate there last month, boring, ate there last year, boring. The place is a boring diner, that is in the beginning of town. Luckily, other eateries are in the town so you don't need to eat here. best of all, Liberty is a short drive and the food selection and amount of places to eat are plentiful. Don't waste your time here. The bar drinks are watered down and taste funny.”

Aug 14, 2009 by Jose from Liberty
Overall Rating: 1
Food:[1] • Service:[2] • Atmosphere:[1]

• Nothing.
• This place is lost in time.

“Classic boring food. The Hamburger buns are very dry. The French fries are small portioned. Even the breakfast menu comes up short, small eggs, small toast and small French fry portion. Save your money and go to the Liberty Diner. Its 3 miles away.”

Jul 29, 2009 by Ricky from scranton
Overall Rating: 2
Food:[2] • Service:[4] • Atmosphere:[1]

• Always empty and seats available.
• No air conditioning in the summer. They have the front door held open for fresh air.

“They never have hot water to wash your hands and most of the time no paper towels or toilet paper. After repeated attempts to wash my filthy hands since everything is dirty in town and this being the only place in town to eat, I found the hot water valve turned off under the basin sink. Rarely have anything to wash your hands with other then a dirty bar of soap left out on the basin sink. There only interest is your money and the food is boring and best eaten when you haven't eaten in 2 days. I order everything on bread since the burger buns are so dry they could cut your lip. Don't drink the water.”

Jul 29, 2009 by Livingston from Quebec
Overall Rating: 3
Food:[3] • Service:[3] • Atmosphere:[2]

• The dining room is clean because I have rarely seen it used.
• Food barely passable. Hamburger buns are dry-dry and need toasting.

“The meals are really quite boring and everything in the veggie department comes from a can or box. The eggs in the morning are the small or medium size. They come with a portions of fried frozen potatoes. They have a bar there, but only the locals patronize the place and drink beer from the bottle only. Everything else in the alcohol department is inferior tasting. With all the places to dine in Liberty a short 8 miles away, exit 100, route 52 and quality ice cream at Fiddlers on route 17, save your money and patience and go elsewhere.”

Popular Restraurants in Livingston Manor

The New Robin Hood Diner Old Rte 17 , Livingston Manor, NY Phone - (845) 439-4404 Restaurant Type: Diner User Rating: 4.5    Aug 29, 2009 by Mike from Manhattan — "Ate there once, boring. Ate there last month, boring, ate there last year, boring. The place is a boring diner, that is" [more] Aug 14, 2009 by Jose from Liberty — "Classic boring food. The Hamburger buns are very dry. The French fries are small portioned. Even the breakfast menu" [more] Read all user reviews »