The Elias Cole

Photos of The Elias Cole, Sussex

• Add your own photo of The Elias Cole

User Reviews for The Elias Cole

• Add Your Own Review »

Nov 28, 2007 by Paula from Westbrookville, NY
Overall Rating: 8
Food:[8] • Service:[8] • Atmosphere:[8]

• The veggies are canned.

“This restaurant is exactly what it is. If you are looking for fancy, hip, or current you are in the wrong place. The service is always good. It's old fashioned cooking; it's what food tasted like when I grew up in the 70's. Aside from the veggies the food has always been good. The pies are amazing, this from someone who thought she didn't like pie. We make a special trip to buy them for the holidays just like my husband's grandfather did.”

1 of 1 people found this review helpful.

Oct 26, 2006 by queeks from springfield nj
Overall Rating: 8
Food:[7] • Service:[7] • Atmosphere:[7]

• Like the home-style cooking and the old fashioned atmosphere.
• Canned vegetables.

“When I get a yearning for meat loaf as I like it, I go to The Elias Cole and combine it with an excursion to Highpoint. Just basic on the menu but the standard fare, meat loaf, turkey and roast beef is great. Served with thick white bread, it's like a meal from the 1950's if that is your desire. The vegetables are canned. The pies are home-made. Knotty pine just like years ago. Never had breakfast there but it were just ending and looked good. Limited menu. ”

Popular Restraurants in Sussex

View all restaurants in Sussex

Double S Diner Inc 154 Route 23 , Sussex, NJ Phone - (973) 875-8419 Restaurant Type: Diner User Rating: 8.0    Oct 19, 2007 by micheal muller from vernon — "The atmosphere takes u back to the 60s an 50s, the music, the memorabilia, the food was very good, the service was good" [more] Read all user reviews »

Domenicks Pizza Rr 23 , Sussex, NJ Phone - (973) 875-5575 Restaurant Type: Pizza restaurants Add your own review »

Tj's Pizza 39 Loomis Ave , Sussex, NJ Phone - (973) 875-0700 Restaurant Type: Pizza restaurants User Rating: 6.0    Apr 30, 2008 by Karl from Sussex — "This pizza is amazing! My friends and I get a pie at least once a week and we have never been disappointed. In fact, I" [more] Read all user reviews »

Fountain Square Inn Inc 82 Main St , Sussex, NJ Phone - (973) 875-4198 Restaurant Type: Bars and lounges User Rating: 4.0    Feb 15, 2008 by Jimmy — "As avid outdoorsmen I was surprised when I found this little gem of a spot that offers a great lunch, a great beverage" [more] Read all user reviews »

Sussex Inn Inc 9 Main St , Sussex, NJ Phone - (973) 875-3000 Restaurant Type: Bars and lounges User Rating: 5.5    Dec 4, 2007 by robert curliss from sussex — "No handicap facilities at all, food was cold and the manager was very shallow and uncaring about my concerns with the" [more] Read all user reviews »