Portage Restaurants

Portage restaurant reviews

View all Portage restaurant reviews

Cimaroli's Supper Club
Feb 15, 2009 by Tera from New Lisbon, WI
Overall Rating: 9
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[9]

• The food was amazing. Everyone in our party was in agreement about how good it was!
• The wait time to be seated was long (1.5 hours) but, I do have to say, well worth time!

“Unbelievable! The wait was a little long, but the food was served quickly and exactly as we ordered it. The waiter was friendly and attentive, even though he was extremely busy on Valentine's Day. We will definitely be going back again. In fact, as we were leaving, we were planning the next reason to go to Cimaroli's!”

Cimaroli's Supper Club
Sep 19, 2008 by Ashley from Dalton
Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[8]

• Steak, friendly service.
• More appetizer selections.

“This is a great restaurant. The steak is wonderful. The service could be better but the servers usually have a great amount of tables. The fact that they have people clean off your plates right away is awesome. There is no room for children to play so it is a great idea to call ahead. The wait is not that bad especially for the steak. If you get a chance to come here I would. My family and I go at least 3 times a month. Also, if you do choose to go on Weekends go at a early time like 4:30, not many people are there.”

Cimaroli's Supper Club
Mar 24, 2008 by Anne from Madison
Overall Rating: 5

• Good steak and drinks.
• Smokey, loud, bad service.

“I would have reviewed this restaurant very well that was until I notice how much they charged to my card. I went with a larger group and the food was pretty decent. The place is loud and smoky, not good for younger children. The waitress was a bit slow to respond and not very friendly, but the price was good and so were the drinks. We asked if the tip was included or if we could leave cash on the table. We were told that cash was fine so I picked up the tab and someone else left cash, 20% tip for a not so great waitress. Then this morning I see that they added a 15% tip onto my bill. I called to ask them about this and to explain that a tip was left and we were told it would not be charged. Well, they said that it is standard practice to add on the tip and the person who told us otherwise was wrong. Great, a 35% tip for a bad waitress. I would have said decent food for a good price, but after the total cost of our trip it is instead not bad food for a very high price. We will not be back.”

Cimaroli's Supper Club
Jan 25, 2008 by Tammy from Madison
Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[7]

• Loved the food, and the service.
• Smokey bar and long wait.

“Worth the drive. Family run - generous portions. Bar is smoky but, it's worth it. Be prepared to wait for your table if you go on the weekend. It's packed. Nothing for small kids to keep them occupied - more for adults.”

Blankenhaus Supper Club
Mar 2, 2007 by Jamie from Poynette
Overall Rating: 9
Food:[10] • Service:[6] • Atmosphere:[8]

• Lots of options in terms of menu items.
• Dining room wait staff could be more hospitable.

“The blanken house offers good portions and the price is affordable. The prime rib here is excellent. The blankenhaus also offers a great buffet and Friday fish fry. I have eaten here on numerous occasions and the food and every item on the menu is well above average...”