Buckeye Lake Restaurants

Buckeye Lake restaurant reviews

View all Buckeye Lake restaurant reviews

Pizza Cottage
Aug 31, 2008 by carol from hollymichigan
Overall Rating: 10

• It is and always has been the best!

“I was born and raised in this area - moved to Michigan but still get a pizza from pizza cottage when my kids come to visit - also Ruthie's way (the bomb) when I visit we always eat there. Don't ever go away! I am 62 years old now and have eaten there as long as it has been there.”

Catfish Charley's Pizza
Mar 4, 2008 by Denise from Reynoldsburg
Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• We loved the Tomato Basil Flatbread.

“When we stepped through the door we were greeted with a friendly hello from the pizza makers in the kitchen. The restaurant has lots of nautical antiques hanging on the walls. There is one area called "Eds Corner". Our server told us this was the owners fathers old fishing equipment from the 1930s. Lots of nostalgia and memory's of the way Buckeye Lake was when I was a kid. We noticed a number of large families in the restaurant. The kids were all coloring pictures of Catfish Charley and his girlfriend Big Mona. (very cute) All in all, it was a enjoyable evening and we will definitely go back.”

Pizza Cottage
Jun 30, 2007 by Jennifer from Pataskala
Overall Rating: 8
Food:[9] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[7]

• Food was great.
• Tables to close together.

“The dining area isn't the greatest. It's a little small but it's a pizza joint so I shouldn't expect much better. The pizza is great and the staff friendly. I have only visited twice but plan on going back many more...”

Pizza Cottage
Mar 10, 2007 by Richard from Charleston, S.C.
Overall Rating: 9
Food:[9] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[9]

• Wonderful place that is clean, has original pizza's & is very friendly.
• They need to franchise to keep up with the demand for their pizza.

“This pizza joint is always busy. I go there every time I am in the area (2 times a year) to visit family and have always loved it. It is not common for the patrons to drive 30+ minutes to eat here (like we do). Be sure to call ahead and make reservations for dinner, or you will have to wait to be seated. Also, they have a BLT Pizza that is wonderful to your taste buds but will set your diet back a week (worth it)! The staff is great and make you feel like a regular! I just wish I could find a place like this where I live at! ”