Highland Mills Restaurants

Highland Mills restaurant reviews

View all Highland Mills restaurant reviews

Cafe Fiesta
Mar 15, 2008 by Tina from Monroe
Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• We like everything about Cafe Fiesta, especially "family friendly."
• There is nothing we dislike.

“We have been going to Cafe Fiesta almost once a week for nine years. We love it. Every dish we have ever tried is wonderful. The kids love it too. I don't know what to suggest; every dish is the best one! The chicken with avocado sauce is delicious; all the shrimp dishes are great too. They have great food, friendly service and toys for the kids to play with. The chocolate cake and brownie sundae are really good, too.”

Black Forest Mill Restaurant
Oct 30, 2007 by sean from chestnut ridge
Overall Rating: 8
Food:[10] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[9]

• Call in advance to order crispy pork shank and potato pancake it will change your life.
• They sometimes run out of best stuff call ahead.

“I travel to Germany often and this place could be picked up, dropped in the motherland and be one of the better places to dine. In addition to the great authentic food, great music and real Germans (in Germany there are few actual Germans serving food and beer, they have been replaced by eastern Europeans) the place is about fun. Loud fun at its best, go with a good group of friends, designate drivers, call ahead and make sure they will set aside the most important food orders for you. You must order the potato pancakes (incredible and they frequently run out which is why I gave them an 8 for overall), also order the crispy pork shank; it will change your life.”

Cafe Fiesta
May 5, 2007 by Alex from Highland Mills
Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[9]

• The food is amazing, and the people who work there is so nice.
• The employees are sometimes slow with getting to your table when you first arrive, but that only happened to me once.

“This restaurant is one of the best Mexican restaurants in all of Woodbury and Monroe. Everyone I know loves to go to that restaurant on the weekends and we all have a good time. I hope that the owners never sell it and/or close it down.”

Cafe Fiesta
Feb 20, 2007 by Thomas from Monroe
Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[9]

• Cool people, great food, not well known.
• Unless you're snobby and need a really posh place, there isn¿t any.

“First review was on point. Great place, family owned great food.”

Cafe Fiesta
Mar 25, 2006 by David from West Point
Overall Rating: 9
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[7]

• Excellent food, service and value.
• Not an amazing atmosphere, but "homey" and small-town.

“A locally known place, great value because the food and service are fantastic. Not a memorable location, but the food more than makes up for it. Every dish my family has tried has been excellent, especially the Chorizo dishes , enchiladas, green Chile sauce and Chile rellenos. Go there!! We abandoned all other Mexican restaurants in this area after we found Cafe Fiesta.”