Hilton Head Island Restaurants

Hilton Head Island restaurant reviews

View all Hilton Head Island restaurant reviews

Nick's Steak & Seafood, LLC
Aug 3, 2009 by Mike from Philadelphia
Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Great service, friendly people, great food.
• There was nothing I disliked.

“For my first time at Nick's, I had a wonderful experience. I went there with a couple of people and I would definitely go back with more. The servers are internationally spread and knowledgeable about the restaurant and the island. The food was reasonably priced for the quantity they give. I was most excited about their all-you-can-eat crab legs. Even though I did not personally have them, my guests enjoyed them and found that they were delicious. I had the filet. They cooked it to perfection and topped it off with caramelized onions and mushrooms. I would recommend this restaurant to friends who are coming to have a great meal. The atmosphere is also kid-friendly.”

Alligator Grille Seafood Rest
Jul 11, 2009 by Holly from Chillicothe, OH
Overall Rating: 7
Food:[8] • Service:[8] • Atmosphere:[9]

• Great sushi.
• Too expensive for the portion size.

“The food was excellent in taste, but was pricey for the portions. They had a kids menu but also expensive for younger children. Sushi was wonderful but again very small rolls for the price.”

Kingfisher Restaurant
Mar 10, 2009 by Ann from Charlotte
Overall Rating: 1
Food:[1] • Service:[1] • Atmosphere:[1]

• Nothing.
• Service.

“Worst service we have ever had. Started with drinks in the bar during happy hour. We could not get waited on so we went to the bar and served ourselves. When we went for our 7:30 reservation, the waiter only came after we requested some one take our order. When we asked for a substitution to the menu item the waiter was rude and later yelled at me when I made a comment to a friend seated next to me. Our party of five got up and left with out ever eating.”

Old Oyster Factory Restaurant Co, Inc
Feb 25, 2009 by dea from mountain home
Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Fun, friendly and great water view.
• Doesn't open until 4:45 pm. We rode around till it did!

“We got there early for the 50 cent oysters on the half shell and drinks. Staff was friendly, attentive and efficient. Two dozen oysters later our appetites were sated. Crowd was fun and seemed to enjoy this seafood spot tremendously! Bought great long-sleeve t-shirts too!”

Aunt Chiladas
Nov 30, 2008 by Milkco from Cincinnati
Overall Rating: 5
Food:[4] • Service:[7] • Atmosphere:[7]

• Plenty of TV's.
• Food not very good and is expensive.

“Food is neither good or bad. Down the middle and nothing special. Chips and Salsa, which are normally free, costs almost $4.00 and no refills. Service is so-so. I think that it used to be better but have changed menu over the years and now it is not very good.”