Sussex Restaurants

Sussex restaurant reviews

View all Sussex restaurant reviews

The Elias Cole
Oct 19, 2009 by Anthony from Brooklyn
Overall Rating: 9
Food:[8] • Service:[8] • Atmosphere:[8]

• Simplicity.
• Simplicity.

“Good home cooking family owned and operated for several generations. Have eaten there about a dozen times and have never been disappointed. Simple food simple menu. White bread made on site and along with their pies are for sale and remind me of simpler times. The pie is what comes after dinner if you have room. The menu is simple and never changing but I love the fried chicken. A great day trip to Highpoint State Park and lunch/Dinner at Elias Cole.”

Tj's Pizza
Apr 30, 2008 by Karl from Sussex
Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• The food is amazing.
• It is not open 24 hours.

“This pizza is amazing! My friends and I get a pie at least once a week and we have never been disappointed. In fact, I met my girl friend of two years there! The other menu items are also outstanding, and the service matches.”

Fountain Square Inn Inc
Feb 15, 2008 by Jimmy
Overall Rating: 7
Food:[10] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[10]

• The Homey atmosphere.
• Closes too early.

“As avid outdoorsmen I was surprised when I found this little gem of a spot that offers a great lunch, a great beverage selection and an honest opinion on what the area has to offer in the way of hunting and fishing. The company in the bar may be a little too rough for families with young children, unless they are bikers who don't mind an occasional curse or two! A true thumbs up in my book!”

Sussex Inn Inc
Dec 4, 2007 by robert curliss from sussex
Overall Rating: 2
Food:[1] • Service:[2] • Atmosphere:[3]

• Outdoor seating.
• People on the side street were fighting.

“No handicap facilities at all, food was cold and the manager was very shallow and uncaring about my concerns with the diner. Parking on main street was very difficult.”

The Elias Cole
Nov 28, 2007 by Paula from Westbrookville, NY
Overall Rating: 8
Food:[8] • Service:[8] • Atmosphere:[8]

• The veggies are canned.

“This restaurant is exactly what it is. If you are looking for fancy, hip, or current you are in the wrong place. The service is always good. It's old fashioned cooking; it's what food tasted like when I grew up in the 70's. Aside from the veggies the food has always been good. The pies are amazing, this from someone who thought she didn't like pie. We make a special trip to buy them for the holidays just like my husband's grandfather did.”