Carlstadt Restaurants

Carlstadt restaurant reviews

View all Carlstadt restaurant reviews

Steves Sizzling Steaks
Nov 10, 2008 by Carolynn from Mahwah
Overall Rating: 7
Food:[10] • Service:[8] • Atmosphere:[6]

• Mouth watering, finger licking awesome steaks.
• The place hasn't changed in years; hole-in-wall atmosphere.

“Been going here for years. The steaks are always finger licking good and the service very quick but the prices keep going up and the atmosphere hasn't changed. You shouldn't expect much. This is the kind of place that you go for a steak and a beer and definitely not the atmosphere. You have to wonder if they will they ever renovate?”

Steves Sizzling Steaks
Oct 15, 2008 by Rob from Scotland
Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[8]

• I liked everything.
• None that I can think of.

“This cannot be beaten, the steak is terrific, service was fantastic and great value for money, the staff was friendly and I will certainly be there again.”

Meadowlands Diner
Jul 8, 2007 by Val! from Rutherford
Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Lurve the food, the cheap and yummy wine, the total Diner-vibe.
• I always end up stealing too many cookies.

“Amazing prices! ($11 for a chocolate milk shake, a "small" carafe of wine (hardly small) and a turkey burger with coleslaw and a pickle! rock n roll!) Also, nice waitress, free cookies that are super good, I say they are sugar cookies, my mom is not sure but they have a baker dedicated to baking just their pastries! Also, the chicken sandwich here is yummy as well. ;)”

Steves Sizzling Steaks
Mar 29, 2007 by Dave from Waldwick
Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[8]

• Simple and to the point. Good steak and it is not one bit pretentious.
• Parking can be a hassle on a Fri. or sat night.

“The best steak in NJ. The sauce is salty and unique. If you¿re getting a filet always get the large. You can sit at the bar and feel right at home. No phony ambience. Just good food. Go hungry so you can finish the large portions. I go at least once a month. See you there!”