Custer Restaurants

Custer restaurant reviews

View all Custer restaurant reviews

Sage Creek Grille
Oct 6, 2009 by Barb from Peoria, AZ
Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[9]

• Great food, wine & beer selections.
• None.

“We stayed right down the street at the Rock Crest Lodge great! and so this restaurant was a quick 2 mile straight shot down from our cabin. Wonderful food - the Walleye was fantastic. Nice wine & beer selections. We came on a Thursday, in late Sept. so it was slightly off-season already. It was busy but not uncomfortable. I can see why this restaurant maybe very busy on weekends and the summer season when some reviewers have complained about a waiting time. It's a small place-worth waiting if you want a gourmet healthy quality food dinner.”

Steaks 'N Ribs Place
Aug 26, 2009 by Levi from Colorado Springs
Overall Rating: 2
Food:[1] • Service:[4] • Atmosphere:[9]

• Beautiful place.
• Horrible food.

“Can't believe you have any good ratings. Ask for a very well done steak. It was completely raw and cold. Waiter set it down and said that it looked like they forgot to put it on the grill. Ha Ha. Did we want it that way. Said no. Please feel free to take it back and burn it. The second one came back just as raw. It was not rare. It was cold and raw. Ask to have it cooked more and was told sorry we will take off your soft drink price. We were polite at all times. I am 50 years old and this is only the second time in my life I have sent anything back or complained. It has to be pretty bad for me to say anything. I told everyone at our hotel not to eat there. It was horrible. The twice baked potato tasted like it came out of a grocery store frozen food package. It was awful also.”

Captains Table Inc
Jul 12, 2008 by Michelle from Cedar Lake, IN
Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• The prime rib.
• Nothing.

“We were there a while ago (9 years) and still crave their prime rib. No one else does prime rib this good (and trust me, we've looked!). It was fabulous! If we lived closer, we'd be there all the time. We tell everyone who is going that way to go there and they love it too!”

Sage Creek Grille
Aug 19, 2007 by Anne from Green Bay, Wi
Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Creative menu, service, quality of food.
• Didn't have a larger stomach.

“This was fabulous! Fresh and delicious. I wish I could have stayed longer to try more of the menu.”

Our Place
Aug 23, 2006 by Kevin from Roby MO
Overall Rating: 8
Food:[8] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[8]

• I loved my waitress...
• I never got her name...

“An ample to overflowing collection of Americana and memorabilia adorn the walls of this establishment to pique your gazing curiosity. Down home atmosphere. Good service during rushes yet never too busy to offer that 'personal' touch. Good food. Good portions. Good prices. We enjoyed four consecutive mornings in their ambiance. ”