Evansville Restaurants

Evansville restaurant reviews

View all Evansville restaurant reviews

The Old Mill Restaurant Inc
Sep 20, 2009 by Len from Cypress, Texas
Overall Rating: 1
Food:[1] • Service:[6] • Atmosphere:[7]

• The employees of the Old Mill were friendly and funny, the decor was unique, even the cob webs in the rafters.
• The food was terrible. The worst I have ever had. We ordered from the menu.

“As a child I remember going to the Old Mill. I was in Evansville visiting relatives and we decided to go to the Old Mill. It was a Sunday afternoon. We were the only people in the restaurant. We ordered from the menu. The staff was very friendly and often funny. The atmosphere was old and historic in the old wood building. You could see cobwebs from the rafters and it added to the old charm of the place. Several of us ordered the Evansville German Sandwich. It was the worst I had ever had. It was way over cooked and did not taste as good as a pork rind does. The others had the Club Sandwich. How can you mess up a Club Sandwich? The sandwich was not fresh and the veges on it were old and nasty. I do not recommend the Old Mill for any meal.”

The Old Mill Restaurant Inc
Sep 14, 2009 by cari from evansville
Overall Rating: 5
Service:[3] • Atmosphere:[8]

• Atmosphere okay.
• Food and pricing.

“Food was cold, waitress kept taking smoke breaks - forgot refills on drinks, no desserts, left at 7pm, very overpriced. Will not refer to my guests at my motel for any reason, very over priced. Will not return.”

The Old Mill Restaurant Inc
Jun 27, 2009 by natalie from evansville
Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Love everything!
• There is nothing to hate.

“Friday's they have Crablegs in the buffet and they are amazing!”

Pasta Grill
Mar 4, 2009 by LeRoy from Mackey, Indiana
Overall Rating: 9
Food:[10] • Service:[9] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Food, atmosphere, experience.
• Cost is a little steep, but tolerable. Service sometimes suffers.

“I would have to say that the cost has increased dramatically over the years. Although sometimes steep, to me it is worth it. I have been going there since they opened their doors as the Pasta House. Everyone there is extremely friendly to us. I now reside in Lafayette, Indiana and have driven from there to Evansville just to eat there. Great place. The only problem I've had is sometimes the service is slow and sometimes the new waiters are not as hospitable. But I understand that it can be hectic when busy plus learning the ropes.”

Fox And Hound
Sep 5, 2008 by Jenny from Evansville
Overall Rating: 3
Food:[7] • Service:[2] • Atmosphere:[4]

• Decent food.
• Bad service and bad drinks.

“Food was good, but took 20 minutes to come out on a not-busy Thursday night. Bartender was inattentive and put in about half the booze he was supposed to. When I complained to the manager for not yelling or mean, about the food taking so long and the booze being shorted he didn't apologize or offer to take it off the bill or anything. He totally dismissed me. Not good customer service. I won't be going back there.”