Rexburg Restaurants

Rexburg restaurant reviews

View all Rexburg restaurant reviews

Frontier Pies Restaurant & Bky
Nov 20, 2009 by Nick
Overall Rating: 5
Food:[3] • Service:[8] • Atmosphere:[4]

• The workers were very friendly.
• Raw chicken.

“I have eaten at this place 2 times. The first time it was OK the second time it started out great, but halfway into my special Chicken. I noticed it was raw in the middle. It was the special of the night and they couldn't cook it properly. Their pies are very average. And the place kind of feels a little and dirty with all the random dusty country decor cluttered around. I will say the mashed potatoes, beans, and cornbread were very good though.”

Craigo's Sourdough Pizza
Oct 18, 2008 by Cindy from Rexburg
Overall Rating: 7
Food:[9] • Service:[5] • Atmosphere:[7]

• The pizza bar!
• They took away there best products; the breadsticks and sour dough crust!

“I love the food. The lunch and dinner buffets are fantastic!”

Frontier Pies Restaurant & Bky
Jul 22, 2007 by Traveler
Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[10] • Atmosphere:[10]

• Wonderful Staff! They work hard for what they have and the crew is excellent! Wonderful Service! Will diffidently be back.
• Not a thing.

“This is such wonderful restaurant! They interior is diffidently rustic and gives a calming relaxing feeling when you are there! The staff is great they don't bother to badly they actually let you enjoy the experience but at the same time attend to your every need without it being a bother! Great with singles and families alike! The people who own this should be proud of what they have, they work hard and it shows.”

Craigo's Sourdough Pizza
Nov 16, 2006 by Aubri from Rexburg, ID
Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[8] • Atmosphere:[8]

• Good food, reasonable prices.
• Not the best service in the world, but it's a college town.

“Cargo¿s sourdough pizza was exactly the type of restaurant I hoped to find in Rexburg. On a college budget, it's hard not to buy into the "$5 deal" most local pizza joints offer, but cargo¿s has stepped up to the competition. Their pizza is great, inexpensive, and the dine-in restaurant is the perfect atmosphere for a casual dinner date. The buffet has a respectable selection, and occasionally they'll even take requests. If you're on a limited budget, they also have a partnership with a local grocer to have their pizza available at the same inexpensive price as the competition. The only disappointment I experienced was with the service. Staffed mostly by college students, it was a far cry from five-star quality, but rather, was about what you'd expect from any other casual-dining/pizzeria restaurant. The wait-staff was apathetic, or rude, just a little under-experienced in providing good customer service. I am particularly careful (and patient!) If you have any food allergies.”

Craigo's Sourdough Pizza
Nov 16, 2006 by Aubri from Rexburg, ID
Overall Rating: 10
Food:[10] • Service:[8] • Atmosphere:[8]

• Great food, reasonable prices.
• Not the speediest or most attentive service... But it is a college town.

“Cargo¿s sourdough pizza was exactly the type of restaurant I hoped to find in Rexburg. On a college budget, it's hard not to buy into the "$5 deal" most local pizza joints offer, but cargo¿s has stepped up to the competition. Their pizza is great, inexpensive, and the dine-in restaurant is the perfect atmosphere for a casual dinner date. The buffet has a respectable selection, and occasionally they'll even take requests. If you're on a limited budget, they also have a partnership with a local grocer to have their pizza available at the same inexpensive price as the competition. The only disappointment I experienced was with the service. Staffed mostly by college students, it was a far cry from five-star quality, but rather, was about what you'd expect from any other casual-dining/pizzeria restaurant. The wait-staff was apathetic, or rude, just a little under-experienced in providing good customer service. I am particularly careful (and patient!) If you have any food allergies.”