McCall Restaurants

McCall restaurant reviews

View all McCall restaurant reviews

Mill Steaks & Spirits
Aug 21, 2009 by Stephen from Boise
Overall Rating: 4
Food:[3] • Service:[5] • Atmosphere:[6]

• Quaint decor.
• Food.

“I can cook better steaks at home after buying them at Costco. The meat was flavorless and overdone, the char marks are cute, but the steak literally tasted burnt. The vegetables were the consistency of baby food, perhaps a rubber-coated spoon should be supplied. Note: for my $35.00, I got bread, meat, pureed veggies and?”

Pancake House
Sep 28, 2008 by Julie from Moapa, NV
Overall Rating: 3
Food:[8] • Service:[1] • Atmosphere:[7]

• Food was good.
• Very unprofessional behavior.

“I came for the first time with my sisters (one of whom recommended it as she has been there before). Food was good, but we did not get served until l hour and ten minutes after we ordered. People came, were served, ate, and left all around us. Our waitress kept apologizing. We asked to see the manager. She refused to come and speak to us; simply told the waitress they were training new cooks. Never apologized. The waitress didn't charge my sisters-in-law for the 2 cinnamon rolls, but the rest of us felt a little stiffed. I will never go back, even though we will be spending a lot of time there, only because the management couldn't care less.”

Mill Steaks & Spirits
Aug 4, 2008 by Judy Carlisle from Tacoma Washington
Overall Rating: 5
Food:[1] • Service:[5] • Atmosphere:[8]

• Decor.
• Tasteless overpriced food.

“Will never recommend or go back. Prime rib was $22 and the 10 oz filet was 32$. They couldn't provide any tomatoes because they said the rate was up and down. Surprise all the other restaurants had them. It was a good thing my prime rib had au jus and horseradish because, except for the skin it was below Denny's standard. Margaritas were served in a tumblers. I would not recommend this restaurant to go - maybe you could get permission to walk around and look at the decor. After looking around, go down the street and around the corner to Steamers. Very professional staff, food is presented very artistically, delicious meals, they even have tomatoes.”

Panda Restaurant
Feb 15, 2008 by Claire from Boise
Overall Rating: 6
Food:[7] • Service:[6] •

• Decent Chinese food at a good price.
• Takeout seems to take forever.

“I think Panda is the only option for Chinese food in McCall. Or maybe I just don't explore enough. I would give it a mixed review. Sometimes I think it is fantastic, and sometimes I am under whelmed. Overall it is good, and you can't beat the view. Especially in the summer time.”

Romanos Italian Ristorante
Jan 12, 2008 by Andrew from Pollock, Idaho
Overall Rating: 1
Food:[1] • Service:[3] • Atmosphere:[7]

• Nice view of the lake.
• Everything else, the food was horrible.

“You have to be desperate to eat at Romano's. The food is overpriced and underwhelming. Unfortunately, there is no good Italian food in McCall, stick with steaks at the Mill, Panda's or Mexican at Chapala's.”