Milford Plaza Hotel New York

Photos of Milford Plaza Hotel New York, New York City

• Add your own photo of Milford Plaza Hotel New York

User Reviews for Milford Plaza Hotel New York, New York City

• Add Your Own Review »

Dec 12, 2008 by Heather from San Diego,CA
Overall Rating: 7

• Location
• Small room. Outdated facility.

“Overall, the hotel was ok. It was clean, but
very small. The bathroom needed to be updated. Old TV in room, and I could hear people sneeze in the next room (thin walls).”

Dec 10, 2008 by tim from Stamford,CT
Overall Rating: 7

• It was very clean, the bed was comfortable, location was excellent.
• The rooms were small.

“Great location, security was good, rooms were small but comforatable and very clean.”

Nov 23, 2008 by Jessica & Terrence from Charlottesville,VA
Overall Rating: 8

• The hotel was one block from Times Square. We could see it from our window.
• The shower was leaky and the bathroom was wet when we came in!

“Bad: The shower was leaky and when we came it there was water all over the bathroom floor. We had to put towels down. When we tried to take a shower it turned on and off after two minutes! Good: The hotel was one block over from Times Square. It is located near all of the broad-way shows!”

Nov 22, 2008 by Scott from Colts Neck,NJ
Overall Rating: 7

• Housekeeping woke me up by coming into my room at 9 am. Checkout isn't until noon.

“Other than the housekeeping issue, it was a very pleasant stay.”

Oct 13, 2008 by anne
Overall Rating: 1

• Nothing.
• Rooms beds and
  bathrooms hallways.

“Its very dirty and old the beds and bathrooms are not acceptable.
”

Sep 9, 2008 by Mary from Long Beach, CA
Overall Rating: 10
Cleanliness:[10] • Staff:[10] • Location:[10]

• Great Staff, convenience to city walking.
• Nothing.

“Great staff, great location, great price, etc.”

Sep 9, 2008 by Fabrizio from Carbonia, AL
Overall Rating: 6
Cleanliness:[2] • Staff:[7] • Location:[8]

• The security, the lobby and the desk.
• The room and the cleanliness.

“The lobby is pretty good, it seems to be safe with the security staff that check who go to the elevators, the position is excellent, but the cleanliness of the room and bathroom was very bad.”

Sep 9, 2008 by Laura from Hershey, PA
Overall Rating: 1
Cleanliness:[3] • Staff:[1] • Location:[8]

• The location was very convenient!
• The staff was extremely rude and unhelpful. The room was old and falling apart.

“I would never stay at this hotel again because the staff was so rude at check in. They were lacking in customer service skills to say the least. The hotel is in major need of a renovation (wall paper falling off walls, tiles and sinks were cracked, carpet was dirty, etc).”

Sep 4, 2008 by Mark from Toronto, ON CA
Overall Rating: 7
Cleanliness:[7] • Staff:[5] • Location:[9]

• Location.
• Slow elevators.

“Great location. Decent rooms. Very slow elevators. Very busy.”

Sep 3, 2008 by Melissa from Snohomish, WA
Overall Rating: 8
Cleanliness:[8] • Staff:[8] • Location:[9]

• Very convenient to sites & public transportation.
• Hard to reach places in room, not cleaned.

“We were very pleased with our stay! We flew in on a red eye and were able to get an early check in at 9 am! The room was mostly clean (except the hard to reach places) and actually larger than anticipated for New York. We were within walking distance of so much - Central Park, Times Square, Empire State Building, Theatre District and the subways were nearby if we needed to catch one of those. While there isn't a restaurant within the hotel, there are just out the front door.”

Aug 28, 2008 by Fiona from Moseley, VA
Overall Rating: 10
Staff:[10] • Location:[10]

• Very convenient to Time Square and the Theater District!
• I was happy enough with it considering the price and location.

“Not the most upscale, but clean and comfortable and incredibly convenient to the Subway and Time Square. Great value for the price.”

Aug 26, 2008 by Steve from Idaho Falls, ID
Overall Rating: 10
Cleanliness:[9] • Staff:[10] • Location:[10]

• It was clean, safe, and located in a close convenient spot.
• They were doing remodeling but it didn't bother me.

“Small room for the price, but it was very comfortable, clean and convenient. I felt it was very safe and affordable for the price.”

Aug 23, 2008 by Jack from Philadelphia, PA
Overall Rating: 5
Cleanliness:[5] • Staff:[5] • Location:[9]

• Location of the hotel in the Theatre District of New York.
• Very dingy in the hallways and the size of the room was small.

“If you want to stay in a room the size of a walk in or janitor's closet, then this is the place for you.”

Aug 20, 2008 by Sam from Cincinnati, OH
Overall Rating: 5
Cleanliness:[7] • Staff:[6] • Location:[8]

• Location right in the heart of times square.
• Extremely small rooms, poor quality beds, water pressure in shower were terrible, old crusty bathrooms.

“The best thing this hotel has going for it is its location. Right next the Broadway; it certainly is convenient for seeing shows. But its rooms are extremely tight and cramped - barely enough room for 2 people. No outlets in the room at all - poor quality beds, noisy A/C, and in general it was old. Definitely not recommended if you have a child with you - there will be no room at all. Perhaps European travelers are used to rooms that small, but us Americans like a little more room.”

Aug 16, 2008 by Allen from Indianapolis, IN
Overall Rating: 9
Cleanliness:[7] • Staff:[9] • Location:[10]

• Location was excellent - convenient to Broadway plays.
• A tiny bit cramped, but I guess that's the norm for NYC hotels.

“It exceeded our expectations. For the excellent low price, we thought the quality would be less. For the most part, everything was clean and the maids were good. Again, the location was perfect, as we were going to 3 Broadway plays.”

Aug 15, 2008 by Mary A. from La Quinta, CA
Overall Rating: 10
Cleanliness:[10] • Staff:[9] • Location:[10]

• Great location, great experience in NY.
• Small rooms.

“Aside from small room, this hotel met our travel needs in NY. Had a great time.”

Aug 10, 2008 by Richard from Kaysville, UT
Overall Rating: 2
Cleanliness:[1] • Staff:[7] • Location:[8]

• Nice staff for the most part.
• Incredibly small rooms, fungus/mold in bathrooms, uncomfortable beds etc.

“I have to say we were nothing short of shocked when we first saw these rooms. The bathroom barely had enough room for one person with old fixtures, short mirrors and water that ran hot to cold every 7 seconds (yes, I counted). These rooms reminded me of the fleabag motels I would stay in when I was on a college budget many years ago. I would never recommend this hotel, ever. The only plus is that the staff was nice.”

Aug 7, 2008 by Maria from Orange, CA
Overall Rating: 10
Cleanliness:[9] • Staff:[10] • Location:[10]

• The hotel served it's purpose. Great location. Clean and safe.
• I would have liked to have full dining available.

“The location was great. The room was small but I am sure every room in New York is. There just isn't a whole lot of space in the city. My husband, son and I felt comfortable and safe. We would stay there again.”

Aug 3, 2008 by Al from Temple, TX
Overall Rating: 6
Cleanliness:[9] • Staff:[8] • Location:[9]

• It is close to theatres.
• Absurdly crowded, air conditioner and escalator not working, no food deliveries to rooms.

“It was cheap enough. The ambience is too bust to be friendly. Maintenance replaced my air conditioner twice, and still it didn't work; so they moved me to another room (larger, thank God) and the air conditioner there was not much better. Attentive security so attentive that local restaurants cannot deliver food to rooms. Overcrowded elevators make picking up food from the lobby quite difficult. My wife and I had to wait through 5 full elevator cars, on one occasion, before we could leave our floor.”

Jul 30, 2008 by David from Vancouver, WA
Overall Rating: 6
Cleanliness:[6] • Staff:[6] • Location:[9]

• The price was excellent for the location. Right in the heart of the theatre district.
• The room and the bathroom are too small. The escalator wasn't working.

“The Milford Plaza consistently garners high marks for the best room for the money in the NYC theater district. It suffers, however, from the familiar NYC economy room problem as it was too small. Take notes it is undergoing renovations now.”

• View All User Reviews

Learn more about Milford Plaza Hotel New York at Priceline Travel Guides »