|
||||||
|
| ||||||
Hudson Hotel
356 West 58 Street,
New York, NY
|
||||||
|
Average User Rating: 7.5 Cleanliness:[8.5] • Staff:[8.0] • Location:[8.5] Based on 4893 user ratings |
Oct 28, 2009 by
Eyad from West Henrietta,NY
Overall Rating: 1
“First glimpse, you think it’s a fancy hotel, but wait till you get to your room. A queen bed with only 2 feet around. That's it. Barely any space to move or even walk through the room. Even the toilet is so small, cannot fit the average adult person. I think if I was taller than 6 feet, or heavier then 250 lbs, I literally would not fit to set on the toilet. The room windows were neither weather, nor noise proof. You can feel the cold breeze come down on the bed, and hear all the emergency vehicles outside, exactly if you were lying sleep on the side of the street. The thermostat was available in the room, but obviously was giving heat only, so when it was on, the room was boiling, and we were caught between the boiling room, and very cold October breeze from the leaky windows to the outside. We had our neighbor in the next room complain of the same issues, the next morning.”
Oct 21, 2009 by
Cerra from Herndon,VA
Overall Rating: 7
“Great location, unusual lobby - dark, but lovely, very small rooms, but well-appointed - IPod charger is nice, shower/tub very small & narrow. Nice (but expensive) bar.”
Oct 14, 2009 by
Janet from Ct,CT
Overall Rating: 8
“Very cool hotel in an excellent location with amazing lobby, courtyard, library bar, restaurant and roof bar.....very small room that looks like a cruise ship room. Excellent service.”
Oct 13, 2009 by
Stephen from Toronto,Canada
Overall Rating: 6
“If you traveling alone, and your 20 to 30 year old...you will love this place! If you are traveling with someone...you will be very cramped.”
Oct 13, 2009 by
Jenn from Cranston,RI
Overall Rating: 8
“The staff was exemplary, polite, efficient and friendly. Any items we had questions on were answered very satisfactorily and promptly. Directions were well-described, easy to follow and everyone we asked was ready with them. My only problem with this hotel was the shoddy towels and beds. If you're going to market yourself as a boutique hotel you need to cover all aspects. The Hudson seemed to spare no expense wowing guests with it's public spaces, they are all fantastic. But as soon as you get off the elevator on a rooms floor you find yourself in a dimly lit hallway with horrible yellow lights illuminating every room's number. It felt like one of those horror flicks where the guests check in and never check out. The room itself was very nice to look at, trim on the amenities but that was expected. The quality of the towels was that of a lesser-starred hotel feeling rough and thin. The bed felt like a pull-out couch apparatus, attached to the wall, concealed by a hip headboard and wooden panels on the sides. The mattress was very thin and both myself & my husband woke up sore and stiff both mornings we were there. I would consider staying there again. I understand you don't get much in NYC as far as space goes, but that's no reason to chintz on quality of room basics for that much money. And I didn't even pay full price, thanks to Priceline. I would have been very disgruntled had I paid the full rate.”
Oct 13, 2009 by
Sharon from Novato,CA
Overall Rating: 6
“The hotel is in a great location right near Columbus Circle. The lobby and lounges are very hip and elegantly decorated. The room is a joke. Felt like I was on a train. Two people couldn't move at the same time. I've been on cruise ships that have larger bathrooms! The quality of the room is not consistent with a 3.5 star.”
Oct 1, 2009 by
Usman from Waltham,MA
“We were extremely disappointed when we got into this hotel. The check in staff was very not friendly. They tried to charge more money, which is not professional. I will not recommend this hotel to anybody. This hotel definitely does not meet the 3.5 star expectations. The most I would give this hotel would be 1 star, as the rooms are like motel rooms.”
Oct 1, 2009 by
Mary from Southborough,MA
Overall Rating: 7
“Great hotel but the rooms are really much too small. Much much too small. Literally, I almost hit my head on the
TV that is on the wall, as there is not another option of getting out of bed.”
Sep 30, 2009 by
Bryan from South Kingstown,RI
Overall Rating: 9
“Great location walking distance to theater district, room is very small but functional.”
Sep 22, 2009 by
Marije from Manasquan,NJ
Overall Rating: 9
“The rooms of the hotel are very cool in design, although they are really (I mean really!) small. The location of the hotel is great however and the food at the restaurant and from room service is excellent. The rooftop bar is a real treasure.”
Sep 12, 2009 by
Stew from Orleans,Canada
Overall Rating: 8
“Good NYC hotel for tourists who don't expect to spend much time in their room. Hudson is trying to be a modern, funky place - but beyond the front entrance and lobby is just a basic hotel in a great location.”
Sep 2, 2009 by
Susan from Hyattsville,MD
Overall Rating: 9
“The staff was very helpful. The hotel was very clean and well decorated. The hotel rooms were small, but the space was very efficiently used so it was not a problem. Everything was very modern. I did not eat at the hotel, however, the drinks were rather expensive.”
Aug 31, 2009 by
Laia from Barcelona,El Salvador
Overall Rating: 7
“It's a very fashion and modern hotel and it has a very nice terrace to take the breakfast. The personal are very kind and helpful, but the rooms are really small.”
Aug 28, 2009 by
Louis from Airmont,NY
Overall Rating: 2
“The hotel is in a nice location and the common areas are very nice. It's a hip and trendy location. On the down side, the room was ridiculously small for a 4 star hotel. There was only room for the bed in the sleeping area, no dresser at all. The bathroom was so small that my knees hit the wall when I was on the toilet. In fact, I had to spread my knees apart to fit and I'm only 5' 11". Luckily we only stayed one night.”
Aug 28, 2009 by
Natasha from Fort Wayne,IN
Overall Rating: 10
“The Hudson hotel is great and loved the comfortable beds. Rooms are always very clean and the floors are always waxed. I would definitely recommend this hotel to all of my friends and family.”
Aug 26, 2009 by
Tammy from Ludington,MI
Overall Rating: 6
“Great hotel if you like loud noise (music) and scantly dressed barmaids. I'm guessing the younger crowd loves it.”
Aug 21, 2009 by
Yoonheui from Amherst,MA
Overall Rating: 10
“Great hotel.”
Aug 21, 2009 by
Kathy from Bonsall,CA
Overall Rating: 3
“Rooms were absurdly small. They were smaller then cabins on a ship. The bed was uncomfortable and low. The beds actually caused soreness the next day. Hotel halls were dark and unfriendly. Bathroom was so small, that there was approx. only 6 inches in front of the toilet. Staff and security was friendly and helpful.”
Aug 15, 2009 by
Scott from Big Indian,NY
Overall Rating: 3
“Staff was pleasant and friendly, and the lounge was nice, but I would never stay there again. Rooms inadequate, much too small and uncomfortable. Not extremely clean. Very unpleasant stay, overall. Also, interestingly, there is no sign outside the hotel to indicate it is there.”
Aug 14, 2009 by
Kay from Van Nuys,CA
Overall Rating: 3
“The rooms are way too small even by NYC standards. Its a joke. And my room was dirty. The chair was filthy with fingerprints and the bathroom was not fully clean.”
|
|
Copyright © 2009 MyTravelGuide.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
MYTravelGuide is a service mark of priceline.com Incorporated
About Us • Privacy policy • Terms and Conditions • Help • Partner Links • Free E-mail Alert
Site Map • Hotels by City • City Travel Guides • Attractions • Restaurants • Cheap Hotels • Hotels in Asia • Pet Friendly Hotels
MyTravelGuide.com is not a booking agent and does not charge any service fees to users of our site.
MyTravelGuide.com is not responsible for content on external web sites.