Comfort Inn Ithaca [Ithaca, NY]- Hotel Reviews - MyTravelGuide.com


My Travel Guide home
Photo of Comfort Inn Ithaca

Comfort Inn Ithaca 2-star

356 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, NY

79 beautifully kept and quiet rooms, all with interior corridors and away from the main road. Relax in one of our whirlpool rooms and wake up to the great variety found on our deluxe continental breakfast.[more]

  • Amenity Highlights — Pets Allowed, Continental Breakfast, Handicapped Rooms/Facilities, Microwave, Air Conditioned
  • Average User Rating: 7.5 [rate it]
On this Page: Compare PricesPhotosUser ReviewsAmenities

Compare Hotel Prices for Comfort Inn Ithaca Ithaca

Step 1
Enter your travel details:

graphical calendar interface

graphical calendar interface


Step 2
Choose a travel site:
Expedia.com
Kayak.com
BookingBuddy.com
Travelocity
Orbitz.com
See more great deals for Comfort Inn Ithaca Ithaca »

Photos of Comfort Inn Ithaca, Ithaca

User Reviews for Comfort Inn Ithaca, Ithaca

Average User Rating: 7.5
Overall user rating
Cleanliness:[7.5] • Staff:[8.0] • Location:[8.0]
Based on 45 user ratings

Aug 22, 2009 by Abu from Bronx,NY
Overall Rating: 4 Overall user rating

  • No swimming pool, no microwave oven in room, room not clean enough.

“As per hotel description, I expected microwave oven in the room, swimming pool and restaurant in the hotel and good breakfast. Hotel lacks all of these.”

May 27, 2009 by Greg from New Rochelle,NY
Overall Rating: 1 Overall user rating

  • Nothing.
  • Everything.

“I purchased 2 rooms: one for me and my partner and one for my elderly parents, for my son's graduation. Both rooms were filthy and smelled terribly. I had to purchase and empty containers of Febreeze and Oust just to make the rooms tolerable. The sliding door screens had holes and let in the flies and the AC did not work but blew hot air. If it weren't for the local graduation you couldn't have paid me to stay there.”

Sep 8, 2008 by Saurabh from Framingham, MA
Overall Rating: 7 Overall user rating
Cleanliness:[7] • Location:[10]

  • Good room for the price.
  • Not clean.

“If you plan on staying a night in Ithaca and do not care too much about relaxing in the hotel, I would recommend this to you. The location is very good. It is very close to all the major shops like Target, Wegmans, Wal-Mart and is located on Route 13 which is also an advantage. I only wish the hotel was clean. There is a Hampton Inn on the other side of the road that I highly recommend. For $20 extra, there is a lot of difference.”

Aug 31, 2008 by Queenie from Glastonbury, CT
Overall Rating: 8 Overall user rating
Cleanliness:[8] • Staff:[8] • Location:[8]

  • Close to everything, very clean.
  • Recommend putting an extra set of towels in rooms - would feel more luxurious.

“We rented two rooms for visits to Ithaca College and Cornell University. Hotel within 15 minutes from each; 10 minutes to the Commons. Easy to find on highway but walking possible (sidewalks and street lights) to Friendly, Wal-Mart. High school-age children loved location. Easy to find on highway but walking possible (sidewalks and street lights) to Friendly, Wal-Mart.”

Aug 16, 2008 by Wayne from Altoona, PA
Overall Rating: 8 Overall user rating
Cleanliness:[8] • Staff:[9] • Location:[8]

  • Convenient, clean and friendly.
  • A little pricy for a Comfort Inn.

“Pretty convenient for our needs. Staff was all very friendly. The room was clean and there were no safety concerns.”

Jul 20, 2008 by Robert from New Rochelle, NY
Overall Rating: 6 Overall user rating
Cleanliness:[9] • Staff:[9] • Location:[7]

  • The staff.
  • Hotel was not as attractive as I thought.

“The hotel did not have any extra amenities that would make me come back. Exercise room was tiny, small treadmill.”

May 28, 2008 by Kristen from Havertown, PA
Overall Rating: 1 Overall user rating
Cleanliness:[1] • Staff:[1] • Location:[1]

  • Nothing.
  • Everything.

“Terrible customer service, rude, nasty.”

Apr 22, 2008 by Chuck from New Kensington, PA
Overall Rating: 9 Overall user rating
Cleanliness:[9] • Staff:[8] • Location:[8]

  • The rooms were clean towels were fresh, everything worked.
  • Water pressure was low.

“The hotel room was clean and comfortable with Spartan accommodations. Slightly on the small side, the bathroom was in good clean condition (something the ladies like to hear) with fresh towels each day, the sheets were fresh and clean no stains on pillows or carpeting breakfast was continental, no frills somewhat stingy but enough to get you started. We had a refrigerator, iron and ironing board. No closet. The hotel service did a nice job of cleaning up for us each day. Everything was in working order. No noticeable damage to the decor. If I go to Ithaca again I would stay at this motel.”

Apr 7, 2008 by Ruth from Malvern, PA
Overall Rating: 8 Overall user rating
Cleanliness:[8] • Staff:[9] • Location:[8]

  • Very helpful staff.
  • First room had bad odor. Had to request new room.

“Basic, clean, comfortable. Mattress not that comfortable. Air system functional but loud.”

Apr 6, 2008 by Rick from Charlottesville, VA
Overall Rating: 9 Overall user rating
Cleanliness:[9] • Staff:[9] • Location:[9]

  • We liked everything but the 2 things that stood out were the excellent quality mattresses and that they had homemade waffles for breakfast!
  • Nothing.

“Our stay here was excellent. The room was comfortable (and warm!), the location was very convenient to Cornell and the people were great. They had an excellent continental breakfast. We would definitely come back again.”

Mar 3, 2008 by Tricia from Charlotte, VT
Overall Rating: 8 Overall user rating
Cleanliness:[7] • Staff:[8] • Location:[6]

  • Cleaner than I expected.
  • Had to walk up flight of stairs.

“More than met my expectations, don't know why this hotel was rated only two stars - deserves more. I needed to call for directions and was helped by staff wonderfully.”

Oct 31, 2007 by Theresa from Ballwin, MO
Overall Rating: 2 Overall user rating
Cleanliness:[1] • Staff:[6] • Location:[7]

  • The staff was cordial.
  • The overall appearance was dingy.
  • Amenities at Comfort Inn Ithaca, Ithaca

    • Air Conditioned
    • Bus Parking
    • Coffee Maker in Room
    • Connecting Rooms
    • Continental Breakfast
    • Copy Service
    • Exercise Gym
    • FAX
    • FEMA Approved
    • Free Local Telephone Calls
    • Free Newspaper
    • Hairdryers Available
    • Handicapped Rooms/Facilities
    • High Speed Internet Access
    • Ice Machine
    • Iron
    • Meeting/Banquet Facilities
    • Microwave
    • Modem Lines in Room
    • No Smoking Rooms/Facilities
    • Outdoor Parking
    • Pets Allowed
    • Radio
    • Refrigerator
    • Safe
    • Smoke Detectors
    • TV Remote Control
    • Telephone
    • Television with Cable
    • Truck Parking
Hotel Representatives:

Learn more about Comfort Inn Ithaca at Priceline Travel Guides »

Copyright © 2009 MyTravelGuide.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
MYTravelGuide is a service mark of priceline.com Incorporated

About Us •  Privacy policy •  Terms and Conditions •  Help  •  Partner Links  •  Free E-mail Alert

Site Map •  Hotels by City •  City Travel Guides •  Attractions •  Restaurants •  Cheap Hotels •  Hotels in Asia •  Pet Friendly Hotels

MyTravelGuide.com is not a booking agent and does not charge any service fees to users of our site.
MyTravelGuide.com is not responsible for content on external web sites.